WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

And anyway, if pressed to choose I would believe in Lommy more than Mac for being innocent. Sure. But it doesn't make me 100% sure - or confident about it.

After what Mac pulled, I would be 100% sure– but I've just played a game where one innocent lied to get another lynched. So I'm... oh... 95% sure.

[Nerwen]

There's still that 5%, though. After re-reading, Lommy still does look rather sinister... I'm reminded of why I voted her.

Now, Mac tried to get Eönwë and Gwath lynched. So, if he's a wolf, does that leave Shasta?

[Inziladun]

To add to Boro's earlier vote analysis, here's the voting by the five remaining.

Day 1

Shasta > Boro
Eönwë > Rikae
Gwath > Wilwa (did not bold)
Izzy > No show
Nerwen > No vote
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 2

Nerwen > Me
Shasta > Rikae
Gwath > Mira (known to be a probable modfire)
Izzy > Mac
Eönwë > No vote
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 3

Shasta > Annu
Eönwë > Gwath
Nerwen > Rikae retracted after her hunter reveal, then Annu
Izzy > Nogrod
Gwath > Annu
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 4

Nerwen > Gwath
Izzy > Herself
Eönwë > Sally
Shasta > Sally
Gwath > No show
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 5

Nerwen > Gwath, retracted for Izzy
Gwath > No show
Eönwë > Me (did not bold)
Izzy > Nerwen
Shasta > Kath
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 6

Izzy > Mac, retracted for Lommy
Nerwen > Mac, retracted for Lommy
Gwath > No show
Shasta > Lommy
Eönwë > Mac
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 7

Nerwen > Mac
Gwath > Mac
Shasta > No vote
Eönwë > Mac
Izzy > Nerwen
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Perhaps that will help someone. I have to conclude that Gwath is innocent, or at least not a mutineer. It would seem he's been allowed to use an unfair tactic if he is.
Izzy's voting appears highly suspect due to the useless vote for herself
and the votes for Nerwen because, as she said, she doesn't believe Greenie's reveal.
Shasta doesn't seem to have made any particularly odd votes.
Nerwen has three retractions.
Both Gwath and Eönwë made unbolded votes, otherwise Eönwë is like Shasta.

[Eönwë]

Ok, well I'm thinking that we know that we've managed to get rid of at least two of the baddies: Sally and one out of Mac and Lommy. Hopefully th

At best, we have only one mutineer left.

At worst however, I could be the only innocent left in the game, with there being two mutineers and two co-conspirators.


edit: x-ed x2 (computer froze)

edit 2: I x-post and now it's suddenly all gone quiet.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Eönwë

At worst however, I could be the only innocent left in the game, with there being two mutineers and two co-conspirators.

Sorry Eönwë, but that was pretty pathetic indeed...

Yes, sorry (nothing personal).

But really, honestly, would you say that at this moment being an innocent? Maybe you could, just maybe... but that does look soo vile!


Thanks for the list Inzy! That could prove handy. I have a few things at my hands right now but I'll promise to take a closer look on that later.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Now, Mac tried to get Eönwë and Gwath lynched. So, if he's a wolf, does that leave Shasta?

I think it all depends on how seriously he tried to get those two lynched and whether we can believe he's a mutineer (sorry to bring this issue to the forwards again... I'm leaning on Lommy being the innocent one but just can't shake the doubt from my mind)? But I think that would be a case to be inspected more closely in any case. A promising find Nerwen!

[Thinlómien]

I'm here...

I think Shasta is the evil one. Truly, Eönwë and Gwath sound honest to me, Izzy is a cobbler and trusting Greenie and what I'm seeing, I think Nerwen is probably an innocent (*sigh* I wish she'd been a cobbler, I'd feel much better about getting lynched).

I think we've caught three baddies this far, I have no idea who the third is, but two of the mutineers were Sally and Mac, I could bet a lot on that. So, as soon as I have the time, I will look through their posts and look for clues and see if my Shasta-hypothesis rings true or if someone else comes out looking worse...

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Sorry Eönwë, but that was pretty pathetic indeed...

Yes, sorry (nothing personal).

But really, honestly, would you say that at this moment being an innocent? Maybe you could, just maybe... but that does look soo vile!

Ok, well how would you say it?

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Eönwë

Ok, well how would you say it?

I wouldn't say it in the first place... it looks darn underlining, or self-sufficent, or trying to appear like something - and thence suspicious...

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I wouldn't say it... it looks darn underlining - and thence suspicious...

Well, yes it does. But in this game I don't say something because it does or doesn't make me suspicious- I say it because I mean it. It is possible that there are two mutineers and two co-conspirators (Ah! There's a way to say it without incriminating myself in the process).