WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Not sure whether I'll wiggle myself out of it, but that wasn't the point anyway. I got you a dead Lommy-mutineer, even if you might not believe me now.

Yes, claiming the ranger was a risky move, but I couldn't watch how the entire ship just blindly followed her. Taking her out was worth the risk of possibly revealing the ranger.

And you knew she was a wolf... how?

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Sally

Wait. What do you mean I'm a phantom, not the phantom?

Your mom is the phantom.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Brinniel

Your mom is the phantom.

Then I'm still the phantom. Well, half the phantom. Well, not really the phantom at all but still....

Oh, and....

*uses your head to play soccer*

[Inziladun]

It certainly is quiet here, considering all the late drama, So many questions.
Will Mac talk his way out of the noose? 25-1
Will Mith have a reasonable explanation of why she threw her vote away on Gwath? 5-1
Will Eönwë and Gwath show themselves long enough for people to get a good read on them? 10-1

[Boromir88]

Oh have mercy on my soul, I get a constant attack of 'your mom' jokes from my roommate...I come to the 'Downs not so I can see even more o' 'em!

Nerwen, and really to point out this from Mac, which is quite possibly the most wolvish thing anyone can say except if he said "I'm a wolf."

Taking her out was worth the risk of possibly revealing the ranger.

I find it difficult an ordo, innocent, Mac would find it be a good idea to fake a ranger claim and lead to someone else's lynching. I remember one really good fake Ranger claim...do you recall it Shasta?

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

I find it difficult an ordo, innocent, Mac would find it be a good idea to fake a ranger claim and lead to someone else's lynching.

Oh, you missed Izzy getting Shasta lynched last game... (real Ranger, but faked a Seer-dream). Still, it's not something I see Mac as likely to do.

Originally Posted by Boromir88

remember one really good fake Ranger claim...do you recall it Shasta?

Shhh! He'll double-kill you for reminding him...

Another thing: we've killed at least one wolf, but there may be as many as three remaining. And if it's three, then lynching an innocent toDay is the end of us. So an ordo Mac shouldn't be so resigned to his fate.

EDIT:X'd with Mith.

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Inziladun

Will Mith have a reasonable explanation of why she threw her vote away on Gwath? 5-1

don't do reason darling...

But I was tired and really los tthe plot not trusting anyone including and increasingly monomaniacal Lommie.

Also had a vague and unlikely hope that the reason Gwath got extra grace was because the moddess didn 't want to end the game by modfire.

But you can't vote for me so whether you believe me is somewhat academic

I am an ordo, I just hope things are clearer today. Unfortunately Boro who seemed relatively OK is dead ...

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

But you can't vote for me so whether you believe me is somewhat academic

That wouldn't have a bit of a gloating tone, would it? Surely I'm mistaken.

[Mithalwen]

No - well not in a "I am a villain and you can't touch me kind of a way" more of in an "I'm innocent and you are wrong but I dont' have to waste time justifying myself" fly swatting way.

I have just too easily distracted this game... if I were a cobbler I promise I would have stirred up mayhem in this set up - go and have a look at Sauce's game if you want to see what I am like when I have nothing left to lose.

And Boro and Nerwen who I have wolfed with know that there is no way I would have missed a kill.

Now I really have very little time to make my mind up so I am not going to waste it justifying myself further.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Izzy

The "entire" ship did not follow her blindly.

That's true. The cobblers followed her seeing.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

And you knew she was a wolf... how?

I guess I was only 99% or so sure. I definitely felt sure enough.

Originally Posted by Inziladun

Will Mac talk his way out of the noose? 25-1

Aw, come on. I'm sure my chances are at least 20-1 or 15-1.

Originally Posted by Boro

Oh have mercy on my soul

You mom have mercy on your soul.

Originally Posted by Boro

I find it difficult an ordo, innocent, Mac would find it be a good idea to fake a ranger claim and lead to someone else's lynching.

With a certain wolf campaigning your lynch and the village blindly following it? A ranger can buy you another day by saving someone from dying, a dead wolf serves the exact same purpose. There was a minor chance that Lommy was not a wolf, but there was a decent chance that either the ranger was already dead, or would manage to stay hidden.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

So an ordo Mac shouldn't be so resigned to his fate.

I have reasonable doubts I'll be able to, but I'm trying my best to convince people.