WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Mac

If so, then I have overlooked them. Please educate me: Show me the reasons, but please show me reasons that merited a defense.

If you're interested, you must go and see them for yourself, I won't start playing games like this at 4.30am.

Originally Posted by Mac

And if you would have put it like that earlier, I wouldn't have had to explain myself.

I seldom mean everything I say totally literally. Okay, I know, you could disregard everything I say based on this but just generally, use of common sense is allowed.

Originally Posted by Mac

Dare. Of course a wolf might do that. But what would an innocent do who is attacked by someone who he thinks is innocent? Change his opinion immediately and counter-attack, or point out what's wrong and carry on without much consequence?

Wonder why the attack came and if the accusator is merely mistaken or if s/he's evil.

Originally Posted by Mac

Err, I think you asked me that on Day3? So Day1 is not all that far back. Also, I wanted to cover all days and state that at no time I had just been agreeing with everyone.

Fair point. I feel like this game has lasted for a dozen days already. Anyway, my point remains. Day1 is Day1 (ie random and yes I know all in this game is random but Day1 is still more random than others) and it is weird you mention it first. Nit-picking maybe, yes, but that's a wolf-catching trick I learned from Aganzir the Queen of Nit-picking. It shows clearly what went through your mind.

Originally Posted by Mac

I wouldn't consider that generic, actually. If you'd add an example or two, I'd be pleased.

Alright, it might be good for myself too to look at it more in-depth, but like I said it's 4.30 now and I've been silly enough to stay awake this long so I won't stay here anymore... but I'll look at it toMorrow if you two are still alive and it feels relevant.

Originally Posted by Mac

I don't think I ignored the serious side. At any rate my reply was not just joking. Maybe my reply wasn't very in-depth, but what would you reply to a question like that?

I don't know, but if I was innocent I wouldn't reply anything so wolvishly phrased. I took your reply as just joking, but if it wasn't, I must take your word for it.

Originally Posted by Mac

Oh, boy... Maybe you should read what I wrote over again. I said I still don't think you're a mutineer.

Yes, you said this:

Originally Posted by Mac

Reading over it again, it is actually a very finely crafted piece of demagogy. Now I have to make up my mind what's up with you. Mutineer, conspirator who's sure about an innocent, or completely misguided ordo. My problem is, I don't think a real mutineer would be so single-minded.

And while you're not suspecting me really yet, it is like you were preparing to change your mind publicly.


edit: xed with everything

[Thinlómien]

I think Boro wanted to get that off his heart and doesn't want to lose my good opinion of him. Not that it tells anything of his role, any of it.

Now I'm really going! Good night everybody.


edit: xed with Shasta - there's no difference imo and no idea why they're flip-flopping unless they've seen the light

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Boro

or a night phase allowing the Ranger and Hunter to make another choice.

Which hunter? And the chance that the ranger will still be alive by then is not exactly great either (3 in 11, I think).

[Boromir88]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Which hunter? And the chance that the ranger will still be alive by then is not exactly great either (3 in 11, I think).

I was talking about the decision we made at the time when there was a Ranger and there was a hunter.

[Boromir88]

--Nogrod

I'm doing no good here, either wolves are intentionally getting me riled up to make me go crazy or people just like seeing me blast off.

Edit: changing the "=" signs to "-" signs

[Macalaure]

One thing to the people who've been complaining about the lack of information in this game setup: Don't forget that the mutineers got lucky and killed the seer right away. On average we'd have a lot more information with this setup. Also, we don't know how well or badly we are actually doing, so I think this criticism is rather early.

[Boromir88]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

One thing to the people who've been complaining about the lack of information in this game setup: Don't forget that the mutineers got lucky and killed the seer right away. On average we'd have a lot more information with this setup. Also, we don't know how well or badly we are actually doing, so I think this criticism is rather early.

True, we don't know...and my complaining isn't an attack against Brinn. (I hope you, Brinn, haven't taken it as such). I'm here, I may kick and scream about it, but I'm here and I'm participating because I want to be. And that is the testament to Brinn's creativity and ingenuity. I whine, but that doesn't mean Brinn's made any kind of mistake or done an awful job.

I just gripe, because the truth is it sucks to not know anything. It sucks to not be able to do what I normally would do, and when I actually do feel like I made a good choice, it sucks to get bombarded with more griping from mates about what a stupid decision you made. Even after defending it, and arguing for it, it's still "how could you even make that mistake...oh and Boro led it!" I'll admit a mistake, but in my opinion, I didn't make one with Mira...maybe I have somewhere else, only time will tell.