Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[Nerwen]

Can I just clarify something? The reason I didn't like Sally's "flaw in the plan" business, and her push for a triple-lynch, is not that I'm so opposed to lynching Gil, but because it looks to me like she might have been seeking a way to "accidentally" de-rail the double-lynch. A risky business, certainly, but I wouldn't be surprised at a wolf panicking at that situation.

Re: Sally's post at #1609.

Ah... now this is a start, Sally. Not much of a start, but a start. In your own post that you quoted above, you say that it's "irrelevant" who my packmates were in that game. Not so: one of them was Nogrod, and the idea to kill you came from him.

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Notice that I came up with the thought, not Morm, as Nerwen suggested (which if I remember right is the biggest piece of her case against me besides the double lynch day).

Yes, you came up with a weak reason to suspect someone already suspected on equally weak grounds– which completely contradicted yours, by the way. (In contrast, quite a number of people thought the kill pointed to Nogrod... but no-one was willing to base a case against him on that alone.)

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

In fact, Morm actually disagreed with my reasoning above. Granted, he could have been bluffing to distance himself from me, but it seemed pretty genuine for Morm so I'll take it at face value, at least as much as I'd trust a wolf.

morm disagreed because his "theory" of why I was a wolf depended on my knowing perfectly well there was a Ranger... and lying about it. Have you actually not realised that yet?

However, the fact that you haven't is a point in your favour, as you'd think mormewolf would have told you at Night. Hmmn.

But anyway, Sally, I asked for your current case... the one which has to take into account the heavy attack on me from a known wolf. I'm not trying to trap you: I want to give you a chance to explain yourself. You're going to have to do better than you have so far.

I'm torn at the moment. It seems to me that your behaviour towards me could mean one of two things:

1. You're a wolf. You made a "me-too" leap for me when morm attacked me, without noticing that your reasoning contradicted his. You continued "suspecting" me after morm was exposed, without coming up with an explanation, because you weren't thinking like an innocent.

2. You're an ordo. You haven't had time to pay much attention to the game, and you're suspecting me out of habit and stubbornness.

General comment: the reason I'm findiing it so hard to make up my mind is that I've played a game in which the following things happened:

1. Rikae (wolf) and I (ordo) fought bitterly for a couple of Days.
2. Rikae was exposed by the Seer.
3. Sally pushed very hard to have me lynched instead of the known wolf Rikae, because she was "so stinking sure" I was a wolf too.
4. Sally got lynched next Day for her blatant attempt to save Rikae.
5. Sally turned out to be an ordo.

I have to go out now– I hope to be back in an hour or so.

EDIT: X'd with Rune and Brinniel.