Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[Nerwen]

Yes, I'm here.

EDIT: x'd with two Greenies. So you're going. Well, 'bye then.

[Thinlómien]

My first reaction to all that's happened was: "WHAT?!?"

Not because I'm particularily surprised to see Agan go (and revealed innocent after all...) or anything. But the reactions to her death are most baffling.

Boro's "ooh see they tried to frame me" looks just so false. I don't think Agan's death points at Boro especially, so he just seems to be exaggerating way too much.

Also, Nerwen's laconic words

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Well, that was predictable.

strike me as fishy. I cannot see the kill as that predictable. I mean, I'm not surprised to see Agan go but I didn't expect it either. Nerwen's reaction looks like the classic wolf mistake of supposing their kill was more obvious than it actually was. (On the other hand, all this criticims towards her comment also looks like the classic mistake of taking one random comment too seriously... )

Ilya's overreacting too, but in her case it looks the most innocent. She's still rather new to this game after all, and her feelings sound genuine-ish.

I will be back in some hours and will post more. I want to talk about the tp-Boro issue for it certainly deserves some criticism...

[Nerwen]

Let me explain.

When Boro did that little bit about "signing Agan's death-warrant", and tp joined in by proclaiming that if Agan died he would go after Boro, I thought it looked like a set-up.

I guessed that either

a.) they were innocents trying to sick the wolves onto Agan because they'd both independently decided that she wasn't the Seer and might become a lynch-candidate... in which case the wolves might well take a look at her and decide that yes, she looked appetising.

or

b.) they were guilty and were going to kill Agan and then make the above claim.

So I thought there was a good chance Aganzir was going to get it.

EDIT: word left out.

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by me

Because that's sort of why I declared her innocent and said what I did about her. I thought for sure she was not a WW, and not the Seer, but an Ordo that was likely to be a lynching distraction to other Ordos, and therefore thought it best that she die during the Night. So I did what I could to make her look like an attractive target.

Originally Posted by Shasta

That does it. Since, as far as I know, this game isn't innocent vs. innocent, there's no way you can be innocent. I don't believe this.

Oh, you don't say? You should really go ask Dancing Spawn about the time I tried to set her up to die. I was an Ordo in that game too.

Lommy and Nogrod might remember that. It was in their WerePenguin game.

I believe I also lied that I was the Hunter in that game. But no doubt lying about being the Hunter means that you can't possibly be innocent in your book.

Hate to say it, lad, but I'm way meaner and evil when I'm an Ordo than I am when I'm a WW.

Originally Posted by me

4) The Seer has almost certainly checked us by now.

Originally Posted by Green

Why do you think so? Or rather, it's somewhat obvious what the reasoning behind that is, the question is what makes you reason that way? (Oh, and it wasn't me who complained about complicated sentences, was it? ) My, that question really is horrible. If you don't get what it means (I'm almost ready to call you genius if you get it), then just answer the original question. Sorry to be so unclear.

Erm... huh?

Okay, let's see if I can make any sense of that and answer what I think your question might be.... I would say that for sure half of my statement was true as of yesterday, and I think that it's probable that the entire statement is true as of today, but I don't know for certain at this time.

Cool?

I'm running late for work now. Be back in a few hours.