Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[Eönwë]

I'd better post my thoughts then

Slighly leaning suspicious:

Gwathagor- Not sure, but I'm getting some bad vibes from him. DEEP under my radar- I don't like it.
Nerwen- She's playing? Oh, yes. She's definitely under my radar, and doesn't seem to be there for a good reason.

Slighly leaning innocent:

Boromir88- He seems ok to me so far.
Gil-Galad- Hasn't posted very much and misssed start. Probably innocent.
Greenie- Seems innocent, and sensible. Knows what she's doing and what she wants to do.
Lommy- Doesn't seem too bad. Not as innocent as yesterday, though.
mormegil- Quiet and intuitive.
Rune- Came in late, but seems like he has some good intentions.

Somewhere in the middle:

Aganzir- Many lengthy posts, and analyses a lot. Expands all her comments a lot. Not sure really, but doesn't seem completely benign.
Brinniel- After a bad start, she seems to have redeemed herself in my eyes.
Ilya- Seemed innocent at first but I'm not so sure any more.
Kath- Determined. Sadly she's determined to kill me, but that doesn't really say whether she's innocent or wolf. Used to be under my radar but no longer.
Nogrod- Other than the Boro-Nog thing he seems quite quiet, but maybe that's just me.
Sally- Not as loud as usual. Could be because of RL, but maybe she's playing sneakily on purpose, and plannin behind the scenes. Need to see more of her.
Shasta- I'm completely at a loss. None of his posts ever give me a strong opinion, and I keep on flip-flopping between thinking he's slightly suspicious and slightly innocent. No strong feeling about him.
The Ka- Not really sure, but she seems to be quiet and under my radar.
the phantom- Well, he's the phantom. Probaby the innocent type.

If I'm still alive tomorrow I'll go into more detail.

Originally Posted by Rune Son of Bjarne

Please decide if you are a lackey of The Phantom or of the Mods.

Definitely not the phantom!

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Eonwe

Shasta- I'm completely at a loss. None of his posts ever give me a strong opinion

Augggggh. *flail*

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Augggggh. *flail*

By the way I meant a strong opinion of you, not whether you had any stong opinions. Just in case you thought I meant it that way.

[Eönwë]

Wait. I said morm felt quiet. But it seems he has more posts than me (not after this post though). He goes right up into the suspicious list for being so under my radar.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Strong opinions. Strong opinions.

Okay.

Phantom annoys me, but that's usual. I think he's probably innocent this time.

Still think Brinniel and Nerwen are innocent, as well.

Lommy and Aganzir also feel good.

Gwath and Eonwe are both under the radar with me. And where's Sally? If any of those three were lynched, I probably wouldn't shed too many tears. (Sorry guys!)

I still think THE Ka needs to be looked at.

Morm speaks sense. Boro as well, but I'm getting a weird vibe from him, and wouldn't put it past him to want to fool an innocent Phantom by being - I'm sorry, I can't think of another word for it - sycophantic. (Pun intended.)

I'm drawing a blank where Nogrod is concerned, but am inclined to trust Greenie.

That's all for now.

Edit: X'd with two Eonwe's.

[satansaloser2005]

Heh. Sorry, this just caught my eye.

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Gwath and Eonwe are both under the radar with me. And where's Sally? If any of those three were lynched, I probably wouldn't shed too many tears. (Sorry guys!)

Oi! Of all people, the other theater kid should understand how busy I am a week before show. (No, I'm not in it, but I have been doing some costume work and whatnot) Gosh! *throws a hissy fit and goes back to her trailer*



(And before you ask, yes, I'm kidding. Enough of the Silly/Busy Sally Show. I have more posts to read.)

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

She's actually sighing there behind my back loudly enough so I'll just quit for now.

I had to pause just to visualise this. It was amusing.

Originally Posted by Boromir

Alright then, you, Brinn's and Eonwe's interactions with eachother on Day 1. I'm putting things together, hold your horses, but there now you know.

Shasta was buddying up to me because he knows in RL when I run for President I will nominate him as my Vice-President, and he want to be sure I don't change my mind. If you don't believe me, just check his sig.

Now I'll be off to make a proper post...

EDIT: X-ed since #705

[Boromir88]

And if you're talking about how friendly I was to Brinniel at the beginning, don't even get me started on how buddy-buddy you and Phantom have been. Glass houses and all that.~Shasta

Relax alright, it's not so much you and Brinn's manner early day 1, it's mostly what Eonwe's posted, which has been connecting all three of you together.

It's going like this...since I'm suspicious of Eonwe, and there's been playful banter between all three of you, I've grown suspicious of you as well.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Boro

It's going like this...since I'm suspicious of Eonwe, and there's been playful banter between all three of you, I've grown suspicious of you as well.

And again, I don't recall saying anything to or about Eonwe Day 1 (though if you find something, please, do post it ).

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by morm

I think the more the Boro/Nog thing goes on the more I'm inclined to believe Nog a wolf.

That reminds me. One of the reasons I'm drawing a blank (but beginning to be suspicious of) Nog is his vote for Boro today. I can see making someone you're suspicious of a representative to see what they do, but Nog's vote was just extra power to Boro, who already had the two requisite votes before Nog voted. It's kind of like "Hey, I think this guy's gonna stab me. Let's hand him a knife and see what happens!" - it doesn't make any sense to me.

A question that I just thought of, for our dearly departed Moddesses - What happens if, heaven forbid, the village dwindles to two villagers and one wolf? The wolf could very easily not vote, and since we can't vote for ourselves, there wouldn't be any representatives that day, meaning no lynch, and an easy win for that wolf.

Edit: X'd with Brinn. Brinniel/Shasta 2012!

[Boromir88]

When did these happen? I can't remember that happening.~Eonwe

In post 102 you jokingly vote for Shasta and say he would probably be vote as a rep. And in 109 you joke that Fea would make him a wolf, because everyone would trust his psychic powers and he'd vote badly (lynching innocents.

Now while those can be considered playful bantering in post 368 you defend Shasta not so jokingly...

He always seems to be right (well not about me, but generally). Now people can just latch onto him if they think he's innocent and hope he still has his "psychic powers". Of course, this also allows WW to "latch onto him" and not look suspicious.
[...]
Same idea. He seems to have gained a lot of trust lately (Though not in this game, strangely enough- but I didn't know that at the time!) When I said vote badly, I meant that it is bad for the village.

That is a not-so joking defense of Shasta, when you responded to Agan's questions.

[Aganzir]

I don't like it how I conclude that every person I've been suspecting is probably innocent.

And I want to go to sleep soonishly and I have no proper idea who to vote.

edit: xed with Boro

[Boromir88]

When did these happen? I can't remember that happening.~Eonwe

And again, I don't recall saying anything to or about Eonwe Day 1 (though if you find something, please, do post it ).~Shasta

Shasta was buddying up to me because he knows in RL when I run for President I will nominate him as my Vice-President, and he want to be sure I don't change my mind. If you don't believe me, just check his sig.~Brinn

Jeez I mention you 3 and everyone just starts popping out...

Well Eonwe was here before, but definitely Shasta and Brinn, you two have suddenly appeared after being relatively innactive today?

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Jeez I mention you 3 and everyone just starts popping out...

Well Eonwe was here before, but definitely Shasta and Brinn, you two have suddenly appeared after being relatively innactive today?

Well, considering I've been at the theatre since 7:30 this morning and just got back about two hours ago...

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Lommy

I find it really curious that Shasta, Eönwë and Brinn all (well, except she didn't that much ) considered Boro's very random point about them interacting on Day1 worth commenting or even defending oneself against....

When someone talks to me, instead of about me, I tend to respond.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Jeez, I'm parroting Eonwe. But I am leaving now. I'll be back later.

[Boromir88]

Yeah, I slept in until 11am then spent most of the day in the editing labs working on my film before heading off for dinner. I got back over an hour ago, but it's taken me some time to catch up...~Brinn

I know there are other places to go and things to do, I just thought it odd that I made a comment on Shasta growing a bit more suspicious, and I would post more on several people (which I'm still intending to do here, maybe I should get to it?)

He posts withing a few minutes asking me why.

I mentioned it's mostly due to Eonwe's posting, and connecting, you with Shasta and Eonwe. Then you appear withing a couple minutes.

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Boromir

Well Eonwe was here before, but definitely Shasta and Brinn, you two have suddenly appeared after being relatively innactive today?

Yeah, I slept in until 11am then spent most of the day in the editing labs working on my film before heading off for dinner. I got back over an hour ago, but it's taken me some time to catch up...

[Brinniel]

Who I think is innocent:

Gil-Galad: Like everyone else, I think he would've shown up by now if he were anything other than an ordo. I mean, is he even still playing?

Kath: Hey, I think I made a good choice for a rep...the position certainly has drawn her out to talk more. I still agree with a lot she has to say and her posts give an innocent vibe.

Sally: It is kinda weird how she has simply disappeared. I think Sally would at least try to be more active if she were a wolf.

Shasta: I agree with Kath that his reactions and frustrations look pretty innocent.

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

That is a not-so joking defense of Shasta, when you responded to Agan's questions.

I wouldn't really call that a defense.

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Jeez I mention you 3 and everyone just starts popping out...

Well Eonwe was here before, but definitely Shasta and Brinn, you two have suddenly appeared after being relatively innactive today?

Well I think it'll just be those two now, it's kinda late here so I'll be going soon.

[Thinlómien]

I find it really curious that Shasta, Eönwë and Brinn all (well, except she didn't that much ) considered Boro's very random point about them interacting on Day1 worth commenting or even defending oneself against....

(Longer post coming soonish...)


edit: xed with Boro and Eönwë

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

I find it really curious that Shasta, Eönwë and Brinn all (well, except she didn't that much ) considered Boro's very random point about them interacting on Day1 worth commenting or even defending oneself against....

Well, I didn't remember talking to Shasta (which I didn't), so I was wondering where he was getting it from.

He says that Shasta is going up his suspicion list, and then he straight away proceeds to analyse posts that include interaction between us (there isn't even any). So I commented.

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Shasta

I wasn't aware you suspected me.

Well, I don't. But I don't trust you either. My problem with you is that you don't give me the tiniest bit of bad gut-feeling, but others keep having good-ish points against you and I too have noticed some odd things. You seem to be very joke-y about suspicions directed at you, for example (at least lately).

Originally Posted by Eönwë

Greenie- Seems innocent, and sensible. Knows what she's doing and what she wants to do.

I think knowing what one's doing and wants to do is far more supicious than innocent...

Originally Posted by Brinniel

I had to pause just to visualise this. It was amusing.

Haha, thanks Brinn. But that man is just really slooooooooooow.............


edit: xed with Brinn, Shasta, Eönwë and Borox2