Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Kath

Oh, one other thing. Shasta is getting pretty defensive and cross. This makes me think he is innocent as he's quite like Mith in that respect

Ah, is he? I was debating privately what his reactions meant, and that thought did occur to me.

All right then. I'm generally trusting you right now Kath, so I'm going to lean on your judgement here. The only game that I remember Shasta from clearly is the last one I played, and he was sort of unusual in that one (I think he might've been strapped for time). So if you say that this is typical Ordoness from him, I'll buy it for now.

[the phantom]

Lommy for Ner
Ner for Lommy
Agan for Boro
morm for Agan
KA for Lommy (2)
Green for morm
Eonwe for Lommy (3)
Rune for morm (2)
Kath for Boro (2)
Shasta for Ner (2)

So our Reps:
Lommy- 3 votes
morm- 2 votes
Boro - 2 votes
Ner - 2 votes

[Boromir88]

I was not voting for Gwath because of the "contradictory" nature of his post but because of the possible intention behind it.~Nogrod

Yet in your post (370) laying out your reasoning against Gwath...

I'm one of those who were a bit uneasy with Gwath's vote for me as a representative. The contraditory nature of that vote was clear indeed. And it could be looked from the devil's advocate viewpoint quite easily and deemed evil.

Do I have to do an underline job like Shasta? You're connecting his contradictory vote with the reason Gwath could be deemed evil (that is what the word "and" does).

You are doing the very same thing Boro!

I already said I'm a hypocrite.

Well, I'm calling you now. Why did you vote Legate?

Read my posts yesterday and you'll find out...or better yet read why Legate didn't want to make me a rep, he thought I would vote for him, he was right. Someone has to go, I made the wrong choice. I mean no offense to Legate, but it was day 1 and his death isn't a game-breaker. Are you confident a Gwath lynching would have turned up a different result?

X and Y said A is a wolf because of B. So don't lecture about me saying A is a wolf! I have not said anything on the matter!"
(and add B being like "s/he has used yellow socks before or s/he used the word "blue" earlier as well...")

You cared to echo their points, right? That comes about even with saying it yourself, doesn't it?

I'm not sure why you're trying to alienate me on this one, when I brought it up as a possible reason that could point to your innocence. I said McCaber's death could have been an attempt at a set-up, with Lommy and Agan both saying it points to you. And as I said, I fully intend, and still do, plan to pursue that possibility, but I wanted to hear your response to my accusations first.

Edit: crossed with Brinn

[Boromir88]

The three votes thing worries me a little, but at the same time we need more reps...Herm. I was planning on voting Rune, but now I may give it to Boro, so that there's someone else with equal weight whose judgement I'm inclined to trust. I have notes now on most everybody, except tp. Post is forthcoming.~Ilya

I don't want to pressure you into a vote, but I don't think we need to have someone with equal weight. As morm points out now we are assured that there will absolutely be no ties (that will change if someone else gets 3). Also, it's not like Lommy's getting half the power here, it is 1-up everyone else, that can be easily balanced without giving someone else 3.

Although I would thank you for the vote, I will say I think you can put it to better use, if you would like to see more reps in there. Anyway, do what you want with it.