Tol-in-Gaurhoth XLVII: Dueling Wizards Werewolf II

[Thinlómien]

Phantom could also be lying just to cause confusion.

Rikae's return kind of ruined everything. Her tone seems quite honest... yet lynching her might still be the best choice....

Originally Posted by Lalaith

And why is Lommy worried that I was thinking like an EW? I said I was. To catch wolves. What's wrong with that?

Because you're doing it in such extent and it seems like coming very naturally to you - as if you had already pondered those things...

Originally Posted by Gwath

I would not be surprised to learn that Lommy had been scried into a wolf last Night following Aganzir's death, because Lommy's part in that lynching would render her exceptionally innocent-looking.

In that case, why not kill me? Scrying me looks kind of too obvious. Maybe I shouldn't say this, though, since I was half-expecting to be scried by the EW. Personally I believe I was left unkilled and unscried because Mac might have been protecting me and because some people believed I and Agan were in cahoots and thus I would not look that innocent toDay even as Agan was proved a wolf.


edit: xed with phantom, sally and Lalaith

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Lalaith

It's this sort of speculation, Legate, which leads me to suspect you really are innocent. (Aside from the bloody rudeness ) I mean, if you were a wolf, you wouldn't care whether we went for Cailin or Rikae.

Thank you. Speaking of that, phantom, will you please answer that? (look up the question in Lalaith's post I quoted)

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

Phantom could also be lying just to cause confusion.

Rikae's return kind of ruined everything. Her tone seems quite honest... yet lynching her might still be the best choice....

Oh you are soo obvious!
No, really, Lommy, you are trying to keep your distance, appear yet undecided, if possibly you could not find support for trusting Rikae. If you are innocent, by all believe me that Rikae is lying. If not, then it is clear what you are, and that you are trying to do what I just said.

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Legate of Amon Lanc

If you are innocent, by all believe me that Rikae is lying. If not, then it is clear what you are, and that you are trying to do what I just said.

I do think Rikae is lying but I cannot be sure. It's easy for you to say if you're indeed innocent and she's framing you. I have absolutely no way of knowing for certain.

Besides, I tend to say my impressions/opinions aloud whether they're consistent or not. I just write what I think at the moment when I'm writing. (You can see this from my posts where I first state I think something and in the next paragraph I contradict it. Sheesh, I guess that's the famous Lommy-flip-flopping. )


edit: xed with everything since my last post

[Thinlómien]

What does it matter if we leave Cailín-wolf or Rikae-wolf to be scried to innocent next Night? We still can't get a new ranger... Honestly, your logic is faulty...

[Diamond18]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

What does it matter if we leave Cailín-wolf or Rikae-wolf to be scried to innocent next Night? We still can't get a new ranger... Honestly, your logic is faulty...

Why are you intent on ignoring the (very likely) possibility that Rikae is the Evil Wizard?

You're either a wolf or the EW yourself, Lom-dear, and every post you are making is reinforcing that notion.

In fact I'm starting to think it's a good idea to lynch Cailin, scry you, and be down two wolves. There'd still be no Ranger, but being down two wolves would be a major plus as the two remaining wolves and the (possible) new wolf would not be able to kill more than one person during the night.

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Lommy

I do think Rikae is lying but I cannot be sure.

Well, then if you think she is, by Eru help me strike a blow against her side!

So you know she (Cailín) is a WW? Or did the GW just tell you to Hunt her, well, that does not necessarily mean she is a WW, you know what I mean?

Oh, sorry.

Yes, yes, I know she is a WW. I did lots of chatting with the GW, so I knew exactly what he was telling me. As a matter of fact he even made a comment shortly before daybreak asking my thoughts on who the "other three" could be.

Cailin's a WW.

.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Cailin's a WW.

Really? 100%? No way you could have misunderstood that?

Then I think I am going to go for it...

[Diamond18]

Nilp for Rikae
Lhuna for Sally
Izzy for Di
Rikae for Rikae
morm for Lommy
Diamond for Cailin

Rikae 2
Sally 1
Di 1
Lommy 1
Cailin 1

A vote for Cailin is a vote for good.

A vote for anyone else is a vote for evil.

[Rikae]

Go ahead and lynch Cailin if you trust tp over me.
I already have the enemy where I want them.

[Lalaith]

why not lynch Rikae? If she's lying like you claim, she's a ww. So it shouldn't matter to you whether we lynch one "known wolf" (Rikae) or another (Cailín). So why are you so adamant on lynching Cailín, not Rikae?

Again, Lommy, you're off. If she's lying she's a wolf...or the EW. Why didn't you get that? You would, usually, you know...

[A Little Green]

I can't trust your word on this, phantom. The reason is that according your theory, Rikae is the EW (that's why she is to be left to you and the GW, and that's why it isn't the same whether we lynch Rikae or Cailín), but you still haven't explained why would an EW-Rikae reveal as a GW. I think that's the biggest flaw in your claim, or else it's something very obvious for everyone else and I just can't see it.

In any case I think we can shut out the possibility of tp being an ordo, unless he had decided to turn cobbler or else just tries to confuse the village as much as possible just for the fun of it.

I don't trust Rikae. Her claim was, like some said, very oddly placed and makes no sense. On the other hand, I'm not comfortable with phantom, either. So, quite frankly, I'm at a loss with what to do.

Seriously, this game is making me nuts.


EDIT: x-ed since phantom's 863

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Yes, yes, I know she is a WW. I did lots of chatting with the GW, so I knew exactly what he was telling me. As a matter of fact he even made a comment shortly before daybreak asking my thoughts on who the "other three" could be.

"He"?

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

I do think Rikae is lying but I cannot be sure. It's easy for you to say if you're indeed innocent and she's framing you. I have absolutely no way of knowing for certain.

Besides, I tend to say my impressions/opinions aloud whether they're consistent or not. I just write what I think at the moment when I'm writing. (You can see this from my posts where I first state I think something and in the next paragraph I contradict it. Sheesh, I guess that's the famous Lommy-flip-flopping. )

Ah. You are probably trying to be nice, and to seem reasonable, and to seem "typical" (flip-flopping...) but... Anyway. Today's question is about Rikae or Cailín now, clearly enough, and heck, if Cailín is not what phantom says - if he really knows she's a Wolf - then we still have a nice row of pre-ordined lynches or whatever for the upcoming days.

I also just thought of a slightly meta-game reason for Cailín being a wolf. I am not sure whether to say it, since it is really somewhat metagame. Although, not that much.