Dueling Wizards Werewolf II discussion thread

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

There will be no immediate "replacements". If a gifted dies during the Night the GW can scry her roster full the next Night the earliest.

But if a gifted is turned into an ordo by the EW, then that gifted did not actually die.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

First of all there is no basic difference between the two options as the gifteds only work at Nights with special powers (and if the gift can be reassigned in the beginning of the next Night then there is no loss from the GW's viewpoint as the new gifted is fully operational that Night).

You lost me. Sure, if a gifted is killed, then by the nightly order, the gift of that individual already took effect, so there's no issue there. But if a gifted is "ordo-ed" by the EW, that gift is lost to the good team for this particular night (because the scry takes place before the abilities of the gifted). It is only reassigned and fully operational the next night.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Secondly when scrying her roster full the GW is after the EW eg. trying to find out who she is. That is not automatically the same person she would like to have as her gifted so we should leave the choices to the GW and not force them upon her.

That's true. The question is what is worse to the GW and whether we want him to have this disadvantage to the EW (whose minions are immediately replaced). There would, of course, also be the possibility to ask the GW what he wants, or to let him give his decision on this matter beforehand each time.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I think the arguments behind that conclusion were never made this open though, so it was good the issue arised anyway.

At your service.