Werewolf XLII: The meaning of life forever

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

C'mon people... This is no Day0.4!

Wait...it's not? Oh okay, I guess I better post then.

On a more serious note, I was expecting to see this duel between Lommy and Nogrod. Because I'm quite sure Might was innocent (why would a wolf commit suicide), therefore one of them has to be a wolf. But which one to believe?

I think it's more likely that Nogrod here is telling the truth since I've found Lommy to be more suspicious since Day 0.6...her reaction to Might's suicide seemed to come out of nervousness of being found out...and toDay suddenly she changes her mind and says she figures Might must be innocent after all. Very wolfy indeed.

But here's my dilemma:

Originally Posted by Volo

-Werewolves and the Guardian will be told of their victim's role if the attack is successful.

Doesn't that mean only the wolves and the Guardian will know the role of the victim? I don't know...maybe I'm interpreting this wrong.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

But getting an extra wolf-kill requires that we do not lynch Lommy but that you leave her to me

The problem is if we don't know the roles of the Nightly victims, how are we supposed to know whether Lommy was a wolf or not once she was actually killed? For all we know, you could be the wolf, Nogrod. Then all you'd have to do is kill Lommy tomorrow Night and say that as a guardian you successfully attacked her. So, how are we to believe you for sure?

Since I think Lommy's pretty suspicious anyway, I think the best option is to lynch her toDay so we all know for sure whether she's a wolf or not. Then we'll know for sure if we can trust Nogrod. There's a protector out there somewhere who could protect him...and give him another chance to attack a wolf.

EDIT: X-ed with Menel and Nogrod