WW XXXX - The scouring of the Shire, vol.2

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Kuru

And I'd like to re-emphasize that Farael didn't attack me until after I'd mentioned his name.

While I find Farael far from innocent (still a big questionmark to me), I think that's a really weak point to suspect him on.

[Kuruharan]

While I find Farael far from innocent (still a big questionmark to me), I think that's a really weak point to suspect him on.

Not when you stop to consider the ferocity of his attack, I think it is actually a rather strong point.

[Volo]

Tommorow, I think it would do good to inspect people from the "talk-effect" side. Who have been the ones to move the discussion into something we pretty much know is futile and bad for that moment.

I don't think I'll have the time to analyse Brinn toDay.

[Thinlómien]

Argh. While Farael and Kuru both strike me as innocentish as separate cases, their spat seems like there's a wolf involved. The problem is that I can't tell which one (and that I'm not sure about this). It is very interesting how Mac sides with Kuru and Brinn with Farael. That is something that should be looked at more closely if one of them dies and his/her role is revealed...

Originally Posted by Volo

Explain, please, I don't think I understood you.

I meant that when he said that thing, I realised I had a bad feeling like that too and thus he seemed quite innocent to me. Understand now?

Originally Posted by Volo

I think it is a horrible idea to try to find new suspects at this point of the Day!

No it isn't! It would be horrible if we didn't consider on any other people than those we had discussed all the day! I don't find these new suspects worrying as most people are still going to vote (or seem to be going to vote) someone whose guilt they've pondered for a long time, not on any last minute whim.

Brinn feels more innocent now. I think I will vote Menel. But I still don't like the fact that Brinn seems to be acting too rationally to be innocent.

edit: xed with Kuru and Volo

[Brinniel]

I need to vote very soon. And it will still be either Menel or Might, though I'm still undecided on which one.

Anyone (aside from Lommy) have a preference on which one? Since I suspect both, I'd really like to vote for whoever's more preferred to avoid another double-lynch.

[Macalaure]

I think I'm going to vote the Might. I think Menel is innocent, and Brinniel probably, too. All my other suspects are not in the running.

[Volo]

I skimmed through Brinn with a thought and I couldn't find the feel of her being a Wolf. I think she's Innocent. All that she has said has been said with too little flaws for a Wolf - the flaws that Wolves make. From the glance I couldn't find any special reactions to other people that would indicate fellow Wolves. That means:

++Menel

I have one more point to make toDay.


Xd with everything since my previous post.

[Macalaure]

A kingdom for a vote count

Farael -> TM
TM -> Menel
Shasta -> Menel (Menel 2, TM 1)
Menel -> TM (Menel 2, TM 2)
Aganzir -> Brinn (Menel 2, TM 2, Brinn 1)
Volo -> Menel (Menel 3, TM 2, Brinn 1)

left to vote: Lommy, Fea, Brinn, Kuru, and me.

[Macalaure]

Lommy said she wanted to vote Menel, I said I wanted the Might. Brinn and Kuru are undecided, I think. Where is Fea?

I guess I would vote Menel to avoid a multiple lynch, but that would be a truly wasted vote.

[Kuruharan]

To tell the truth, I'd rather vote for Farael than anybody as he now seems the most wolfish to me by far...but I don't want to cause a double lynch.

I'll probably vote Menel just because he seems like he might be more slippery.

[Macalaure]

I would join you with Farael, but only with sufficient support from others.

[Kuruharan]

I've unfortunately had a family situation come up and I'm not going to be back today.

++ Farael

He reacted waaaay to strongly to one mention of his name yesterDAY and then went totally silent. Very wolfish if you ask me.

I apologize for this, circumstances beyond my control.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Votes:

1 for Farael (by Kuru)
1 for Kuru (by Farael)

Seven votes still available and 47 minutes left.

I'm so afraid that the relative village silence right now is going to herald a chaotic end of day.

[Volo]

I highly suspect Mac, very highly! And I ask you to read this post and think about it during the Night!

1. He has never, never felt like this to me. He has felt more present before.

2. I get the feeling that he concentrates on me most of the time, but is undecisive.

3. He is wrong with what he mostly says, or so I feel:

Originally Posted by Mac, italics added by me

Suspicions basing solely on these comments:

Suspicious: Lommy (probably innocent), Legate (innocent), morm (Ranger)

A Little Suspicious: Aganzir, The Might, A Little Green (Wolf), Kath (Seer)

Unknown: Vo?o (no typo ) (innocent, to me), Fea, Sally (innocent), Farael, Shasta

Innocentish: Menel, Brinn, Kuru

I get the feeling that he carefully divided us into these groups, as the possible Wolves seem to lie too neatly. Lily was the partner whom he decided to suspect, look at the way he voted her.
Menel he has always found innocent, which I recall wierd:

Originally Posted by Mac

Lily and Menel

"I found Menel's continuous joking about not being eaten disturbing.
my vote today will most probably be Menel."

Menel finds her suspicious but chooses morm over her for reasons I think are understandable.

Here's an example, while I find Menel very suspicious because of this very thing, Mac doesn't.

Originally Posted by Mac, italics added by me

only considering the interaction with Lily:

suspicious: Volo (innocent, to me), The Might

a little suspicious: Sally (innocent), Farael

neutral: Aganzir, Menel, Fea, Kath (Seer), Kuru, Shasta

innocent: Lommy (probably innocent), morm (Ranger), Brinn

Here the same as before. And I don't like these "suspicious based only on factor X", it doesn't give the whole picture and Mac's real opinion. Seems a good trick for a Wolf.


This was said very hurriedly because the deadline is drawing, but I'll look into this and explain better tomorrow. I hope you will think about this too!


Xd with everything since my preveous post.