Other authors?

[Lalwendë]

Cheers Child! I did suspect that Narnia was the product of his bachelor days - only a man who has got used to living without women could produce a character like Susan.

Fea - Pan's Labyrinth - good call. I reckon you might like Isabel Allende's The House Of The Spirits if you liked that - book, not film, as the film was pants.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Lalwendë

I reckon you might like Isabel Allende's The House Of The Spirits if you liked that - book, not film, as the film was pants.

I've got it on my bookshelf. It was assigned for a class I walked out of just before it was actually due for discussion, so I've read about half of it, but never got around to finishing. I'll scoot it up my to-read list.

If anybody wants to torment themselves with names (like reading the Silm, I swear), take a stab at Gabriel Garcia Marquez's A Hundred Years of Solitude. Sixteen illegitimate Aurelianos in one family!

[Morwen]

Originally Posted by Child of the 7th Age

Lalwende,

Regarding this question.....if you want to see a different side of Lewis, try reading Till We Have Faces. I always felt it was the best piece of fantasy/myth that C.S. Lewis attempted. His depiction of the two sisters shows a depth of understanding that isn't apparent in the Narnia series. Till We Have Faces was composed after the marriage to Joy (Narnia was before). His understanding of women seems to have taken a giant step forward in the interim.

When I first read Narnia, the Susan stereotype did not bother me. I was a young teenager and knew a lot of girls who exactly fit the Susan stereotype. I righteously consoled myself with the fact that I was not one of these airheads but a "Lucy" who definitely merited entry to Narnia . However, looking backwards from a different vantage point, I am less comfortable with how Lewis depicted women, whether in the Narnia series or in his sci/fi--their roles seem so limiting. Still, the feeling is not so visceral that I can't get around it to read and enjoy his stories.

But what of his portrayals of Polly, Jill, or Aravis? Especially Aravis who shows a lot of resourcefulness and a take charge attitude with respect to her life, refusing to settle for her arranged marriage and venturing off on her own. The Susan who is discussed in "The Last Battle" doesn't represent the norm for his female characters.