Seems Like Someone's Rooting for the Wrong Side

[the guy who be short]

Originally Posted by Raynor

When did I define norm as majority view?

That's what a norm is. Normal. Something widely accepted by most people.

Originally Posted by Raynor

My argument was that siding with the evil actions of the orcs may contradict one's own morality [if one holds various moral values to be true], regardless what other view as moral or not.

Surely there is no argument then? If one holds that it is immoral to side with orcs (as you do), and sides with orcs, then this is immoral to that person. If one holds that siding with orcs is not immoral, and sides with orcs, then this is not immoral to that person.

Originally Posted by Salacia

I find that debating the morality of characters in Lord of the Rings is hard to do, since, as a children's story the moral lesson was put in by the author himself. There's a reason why Frodo is endearing and Sauron is a fiery eyeball, and that's because beautiful is good and ugly is bad, end of story.

Strider looks foul, not to mention Ghan-buri-Ghan!