Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

[the guy who be short]

Originally Posted by nogrod

Now this makes me scan to the PanMan again. Maybe this is yet another Valarish plan of the Faithfuls, but I still think that if SPaMman is innocent - and as the Faithfuls knew I would be protected - why did they kill Rune instead of him?

Thus far I have believed SpM to be innocent, but his continued life makes me doubt him a little.

The problem is that this always happens when SpM lives late into a game. People think that he must be a wolf, because otherwise the wolves would see him as a threat and kill him off.
However, the wolves know people will think this, so they may leave him alive in order to let him garner votes.
Or perhaps they leave him because they know that he is influential, but his suspicions are all wrong and so misleading the village.

I think it's impossible to decide.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I'm still a bit at loss with your logic tgwbs. It's just hard to say whether we think this differently (and naturally thinking the other one does it really bad) or are you a Faithful who deliberately tries to make others think weirdly...

I do have a very unique brand of logic, being a mathematician. However, that idea was just me trying to attach meaning to Rune's murder. I can't figure out why they chose him, and this annoys me a lot because this is the first person the Faithful have killed out of choice.

Originally Posted by Lommy

And TGWBS, I think you manage to point out how weird/contradictory Mänwe is...

I have neither said that he has been weird nor that he has been contradictory. I've said I don't like the way he tried to spread the unease and doubt around Rikae.

Goodnight.