Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

the guy who be short · 02-28-2007, 12:42 PM

Mith - That first post seemed very weird to me (and to several others). However, I can accept that anybody can make mistakes. Also, you say the sentence was rhetorical (which I didn't perceive). Most of the rest of what you say seems innocent to me, so I don't believe you're a Faithful. However, on day one you have to suspect whoever you can based on whatever evidence you have. There's sufficient additional information today for me, at least (and I believe I have been your most dedicated attacker) to turn my attention elsewhere.

Nogrod and Rikae - thanks for the (up-and-coming) info on your thoughts on everyone. I'll admit I don't know Roa very well. If people think she's that tricksy, I'll remove her from the meta-analysis and we can just see what Nogrod and Rikae think. I suppose interpretation of Roa's words can go either way - she could be speaking her mind or lying to lead us astray. Perhaps it's better to look at people she's simply avoided mentioning strong feelings about altogether: Glirdan, Brinniel, Gil-Galad, Kath and Mithalwen.

I'm having a look at Lommy next.

the guy who be short · 02-28-2007, 12:56 PM

Re: Lynching Roa, I'm with Rikae on this. Killing the cobbler means not killing a potential wolf. Perhaps if our numbers were smaller, killing her would be a priority.

However, we are 18, of whom 2 are known innocents and one is Tar-Miriel. Our numbers can more than absorb Roa's one vote.

I think it would be benficial to go for a different villager. Nobody is taking Roa seriously because her argument makes no sense. When Rikae dies tonight, Roa will be proven to be the cobbler. Perhaps it will be interesting to see how she reacts. She will be in a very difficult position. She will be unable to sow confusion - her main role. She will be unable to serve her Faithful masters effectively because she won't be able to encourage people to vote for whoever she thinks is innocent - we wont trust her. And she wont be able to follow the village and vote for somebody who she thinks is Faithful, because that will kill one of her precious masters.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

02-28-2007, 12:42 PM	#1
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	Mith - That first post seemed very weird to me (and to several others). However, I can accept that anybody can make mistakes. Also, you say the sentence was rhetorical (which I didn't perceive). Most of the rest of what you say seems innocent to me, so I don't believe you're a Faithful. However, on day one you have to suspect whoever you can based on whatever evidence you have. There's sufficient additional information today for me, at least (and I believe I have been your most dedicated attacker) to turn my attention elsewhere. Nogrod and Rikae - thanks for the (up-and-coming) info on your thoughts on everyone. I'll admit I don't know Roa very well. If people think she's that tricksy, I'll remove her from the meta-analysis and we can just see what Nogrod and Rikae think. I suppose interpretation of Roa's words can go either way - she could be speaking her mind or lying to lead us astray. Perhaps it's better to look at people she's simply avoided mentioning strong feelings about altogether: Glirdan, Brinniel, Gil-Galad, Kath and Mithalwen. I'm having a look at Lommy next.

02-28-2007, 12:56 PM	#2
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	Re: Lynching Roa, I'm with Rikae on this. Killing the cobbler means not killing a potential wolf. Perhaps if our numbers were smaller, killing her would be a priority. However, we are 18, of whom 2 are known innocents and one is Tar-Miriel. Our numbers can more than absorb Roa's one vote. I think it would be benficial to go for a different villager. Nobody is taking Roa seriously because her argument makes no sense. When Rikae dies tonight, Roa will be proven to be the cobbler. Perhaps it will be interesting to see how she reacts. She will be in a very difficult position. She will be unable to sow confusion - her main role. She will be unable to serve her Faithful masters effectively because she won't be able to encourage people to vote for whoever she thinks is innocent - we wont trust her. And she wont be able to follow the village and vote for somebody who she thinks is Faithful, because that will kill one of her precious masters.