Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

[Roa_Aoife]

Originally Posted by spm

To be fair, it is always worthwhile to bear in mind that Gifteds can sometimes appear suspicious, by their nature.

I'm well aware of that- but I believe it's the gifted's job to take care of themselves. We should go about the business of wolf hunting instead of fretting over our protectors.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

What bothers me is that I tend to agree with Roa here (as we should be the cat and the dog - which one of us is what is an open question)...

*ahem* Meow.

Originally Posted by durelin

that's a lot of us to just go at each other's throats, isn't it?

You should have been here for Deuling Wizards.

Originally Posted by legate

I think I now understand how important is that all people post, because otherwise there is nothing to learn. And who sits and says nothing, is likely a wolf (err, Faithful) - or in worse case, he is a villager (who is not worth anything for the community, if I say it very nastily). But the wolves also need to go around and make a mess by putting us on wrong track, thus, if everyone participates in the discussion, possibly "the one who speaks the loudest bears the banner of the Tree".

Legate, you're a player after my own heart.

Originally Posted by thin

When I first read this thread through, my first impression was that this is the most paranoid first day ever. But probably I was just exaggerating...

Again, Deuling Wizards.



As to my accusers, (Manwe and SPM, and anyone else who I missed).

I never "jumped on" Glirdan. I was using him as an example of what not to do. Neither did I say that anyone quiet was a faithful. I've seen villages destroyed by quietness, and wolves come to easy victory because if it. It is a fact the woves, or cats or faithfuls, or penguins, or whatever else the great Mod God's happen to come up with, have a tendency to kill either the loudest or the quietest players. The loudest because a quiet village is easily overrun by bold wolves, and the quietest because it leaves no discernable trail for us to follow. So, be noisy, indeed, but more than that, put some SUBSTANCE into your posts. It's also true that the wolves divide their numbers during the day - some are noisy, some are quiet. They attack one of their own while ignoring the others. Quietness doesn't = wolf. Quietness doesn't even mean a bad player. But quietness does make it easier for the wolves to run the village, straight to the ground.

As I said, I've seen villages destroyed by their own quietnes. But I've never seen I noisy village go down for speaking, except when that speaking is all but hot air.

I'll be back in a moment with some analysis.