all British tolkienites HERE

[Eurytus]

???? This is getting beyond me...puerile? ??? And how does that close the discussion? Sorry, never covered debating in school. Sad but tue.

You might like to read the thread again and then realise two things;

1. Yes, using personal information to try and beat someone is a debate is puerile.

2. I never said the entire debate was closed, I said any debate with people who do the above is closed.

I shouldn't think one would need to go to debating school to realise this.