WWJ Attack of the Werecats:The ppuuuurrfect village

[Farael]

Valier was saying "Lone Werecat and Seeker" for a couple of nights... it is possible that she did not want to give any clues with regard to what the b-day dreamer had dreamt of.... which makes a heck of a lot of sense, or else she'd be helping either the village (by letting us know we have TWO werecats now) or the cats (By letting them know that there are TWO seers).

I still think Formendacil's act is very fishy.... I dont' like it one bit. Lynch me if that's what it takes for you to believe I'm just a hobbit, I don't care... but keep an eye on Formendacil.

[Roa_Aoife]

You make a good point.

Actually, here are my thoughts on suspicion:

Alcarillo hasn't been around. If he pops up today, he'll remain on my radar, but in my experience, players with such low activity are just innocents who don't have time to give proper attention to the game. I hate this kind of play, but it's unlikely he's a Cat.

I'm almost positive that Morm's turn around on Eonwe shows her innocense. If Form is telling the truth, then I can't know about Garin, but if not, then my bet is Garin is also innocent. Morm strikes me as the intelligent sort, and I don't think he would make an unknown appear innocent when he knew his posts would be looked at in the event of his death.

That leaves me and Farael on the list of unknowns. I know that I'm not a Cat, even though the rest of you don't. So that leaves Farael in my mind. If he isn't a Cat, then my next look would be Kath. Others still living can look at Garin. I wish someone else would do the analysis, too, but I'll do what I must.

If Kath is a Cat, then I know Form is a Cat. If Kath isn't a Cat, then I know Garin or Alca is a Cat.

So, since we can't be certain of Form, I suggest we lynch Farael today. If he isn't a Cat, we lynch Kath. In the meantime, if Form is telling the truth, he can dream about Garin.

If he's telling the Truth, that would reveal either Garin or myself as the final Cat. If he isn't, then we'll know when Kath is lynched.

Scenario 1: Form and Farael are telling the truth
We lynch Farael and find him innocent
Eonwe Dies (You're the only positive innocent. Sorry dear.)
Form Dreams of Garin and learns his identity. Since we can't be sure of his word, We lynch Kath, who would show herself to not be a Cat, and we would know Form is telling the truth
Form most likely dies
We lynch whoever Form revealed

Scenario 2: Form is lying, but Farael isn't
We lynch Farael and find him innocent
Eonwe Dies
We lynch Kath, who would then reveal herself to be a Cat, and we would know Form is lying
Anyone could die here
We lynch Form and the Game is over

Scenario 3: Form and Farael are lying
We lynch Farael and prove he's guilty, but the game continues
Anyone dies, since we would know Form was lying at this point
We lynch Form and end the game

Note: These scenarios ignore Alcarillo (See first paragraph)

Edit: Adding the other scenario, which I believe to be the correct one.

Scenario 4: Farael is lying and Form isn't
We lynch Farael and the game ends

[Roa_Aoife]

I have to head out, and I most likely won't be on again till after Voting closes, so:

++Farael

[Farael]

Go for it guys... I'm innocent, but there is only one way you all will find out.

And remember, I'm not saying Form is a cat FOR SURE.... But I have my doubts and I wouldn't put it past him to pull such a bluff.

[Eonwe]

I'll take this opportunity to jump on a growing bandwagon:

++Farael

I'll put an end to this blood feud one way or another...

[Formendacil]

Well, I'm flattered, Farael, that you think me so capably clever, but I assure you that I am the new Seer.

Until Morm's death, I was more of a Junior Seeriff, in the tradition of Nilp's Game, or an Apprentice with PM powers, so to speak. I'm not sure if Valier intended us to be equal partners or no, but I pretty much let Morm hold the reins. It was, after all, his native role, and I had basically whiled away the game being rather flippant...

With Morm's death, however, I'm now in a position where I think it wise to reveal what he knew.

As to my calling myself an Innocent yesterday, it had to do with the fact that I didn't want to reveal Morm's identity to the Cat. I also didn't want to make him a target of a Cat attack. However, I DID want to save myself from an early death.

So, that said, of my four possible Cats, I don't really think that Farael is the one we're looking for. Either Roa or Garin is my personal opinion- with Alcarillo being a potential wildcard...

[Formendacil]

To add:

If Farael wants to be the victim, and prove his innocence, then I'm fine with that. I wouldn't put it past him to try and get himself lynched in the hopes that we'll retract our votes and leave him be...

[Kath]

Eonwe your vote isn't properly bolded. I'm not sure it will count unless it is.

Who has voted:
Kath
Farael
Roa
Eonwe

Who hasn't voted:
Alcarillo
Form
Garin

We have 4 votes for Farael now so if none are retracted even if all the others vote someone else he will die. Even so, it would be better if we could be sure one of these last three would vote Farael, just in case Farael himself takes his suicidal vote back.

[Formendacil]

Wise enough, I suppose, Kath. Allow me to be of assistance...

++Farael

I'll be back at least once before Day End, I'm sure...