WWJ Attack of the Werecats:The ppuuuurrfect village

[mormegil]

Look at what Diamond did after 1 vote for her.

She changed her vote for to Telperaca, the most likely to die today. What does this accomplish. Most likely Telperaca is innocent but an easy kill so it doesn't really leave tracks because it's not seen as overly suspicious a vote. It also makes Telperaca the lead candidate and much more difficult for anybody to catch up to her, including herself. Diamond's voting record really is speaking against her.

[Thinlómien]

Glirdan, would you care to clarify what is the difference of "in between" and "not sure" lists?

Originally Posted by Glirdan

Another point against Thinlo. By attacking Kitanna last, night, she could be sure that no one could draw anything betweent them as Lommy didn't even mention Kitanna once except for the analysis bit which Garin said he'd do (he couldn't post his results). In short, their was not attachment between the two which made Kitanna the perfect attack for Thinlo.

Hmmm... And I don't care to count or find out, but there surely are lots of other people who had no connections to her either.

Originally Posted by Glirdan

True, but if you go back to that post, you said that it's like a random thing. Check if you don't believe me.

I checked. What I exactly said was this:

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

I'd like to suspect Telperaca for a very vague vote which is actually quite random (or so I believe), but as she's a newcomer I will be gentle to her, unless she shows real suspiciousness.

Apparently I said so. I apologise. Anyway, I meant that her reasoning was so weird and she didn't post anything else. I prefer people saying/admitting that they've cast a random vote rather than giving a reason like "he wants to run away." I admit I was contradictory, but I really didn't think so much...

[Kath]

No, no, no! Stop voting for Telp! It doesn't look like she will turn up again toDay and why waste this chance to find out the identities of both her and Lommy.

Yes that sounds very Catlike and I'm sorry, but if just Telp is lynched then we will spend all Day tomorrow focusing on Lommy. We need to move beyond this and if neither are wolves we really need to.

Voting so far looks like:
Eonwe 1 (Farael)
Lommy 1 (Glirdan)
Telp 3 (Lommy, Diamond, Alcarillo)
Diamond 2 (morm, Garin)
Glirdan 1 (Eonwe)

Now look at how spread out that is. On Day 3! That's insane. Please, those who voted Telp would you look at the logic and change to Lommy. This is risky it's true but (and I can't believe I'm saying this) look at the maths. If wither Telp or Lommy is a Cat we win anyway. If Telp and Lommy are both innocent and they die toDay one other will die toNight bringing it to a total of 3 deaths. If we lynch one toDay and one tomorrow that gives 2 Night's for the Cat to kill innocents, adding up to 4. This is safer for us.

[Thinlómien]

Kath, I do get your point. I see you can't trust me and I accept it. I have nothing to prove my innocence. *a dramatic sigh*

[Thinlómien]

Oh, and I sent a PM to Valier asking whether Telperaca will be struck by modly fire or will there be an exception (don't ask why there'd be, but that's always possible).

[Thinlómien]

After thinking about this, I'm not sure if I suspect Glirdy so much anymore. I'll explain why. I don't believe that a wolf'd be so bold and take such a leading place in the attack against me. Simply because as you discover me innocent, he will be suspected and he knows that. But then again, he might be a wolf and claim that no wolf would take such a big role in a lynching of an innocent. Argh. I don't really know. Werewolf makes me crazy. But anyway I think he's worth being kept an eye on.

[Thinlómien]

There are still four people (including Telperaca) that haven't posted their votes yet. We have only half an hour. This bugs me.

The situation can also change completely because of the retractables. I wonder what is happening...

*OOC - I know this is no good playing, but in case I'm going to die toDay I would like to point out that our mod might have been intrigued by the thought of three idols-wolves. But maybe I don't think her that stupid...

[Diamond18]

- - Telperaca

+ + Thinlomien

This is assuming Telp will get struck with Mod Fire toDay. We'll get rid of both those nagging T's in one Day and be free to think of other things, unless of course one is a Cat and the game ends.

Garin, Morm, you're making it hard to choose between the two of you.

[mormegil]

Originally Posted by Kath

Now look at how spread out that is. On Day 3! That's insane. Please, those who voted Telp would you look at the logic and change to Lommy. This is risky it's true but (and I can't believe I'm saying this) look at the maths. If wither Telp or Lommy is a Cat we win anyway. If Telp and Lommy are both innocent and they die toDay one other will die toNight bringing it to a total of 3 deaths. If we lynch one toDay and one tomorrow that gives 2 Night's for the Cat to kill innocents, adding up to 4. This is safer for us.

Kath I could be wrong but aren't you always against double lycnhing...I know we don't have them but isn't this more or less the same? Also aren't you always against killing people to get information?

You've really made this situation an ultimatum. Why is it that if we don't kill Thinlo today we must kill her tomorrow? Your reasoning is based on that assumption and it's a fallicious assumption at that.