Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIX: Ang Sagang Daga, bow.

[Garin]

No hard feelings Farael.

[Caranlondien]

Hmm, I must vote soon.

I tend to think that Garin is innocent. I keep going over his reactions, and they seem genuine to me. Maybe I'm being completely fooled...

I doubt my vote will make a significant impact here, but I've felt suspicious of Anguirel for a while now. He talks a great deal, but I can't see that he's contributed much of substance to the conversation. Says much while still saying little; the markings of a wolf?

I'll join with Farael's vote:

++ Anguirel

[Valier]

Since all this days bantering and arguing has left me confused, my vote shall be for a person I deem most suspisious.

++Glirdan

This may be taken at face value today I must admit my vote is some what hasty and safe. I do not take first day accusations as seriously until later, when some thing can be made of them.

Unemployed villagers can be of little help *smiles sweetly* I swear I just have no idea today. Tah and Hope we lynch a wolf with all this campanigning and not a loudmouth innocent!

[Lhunardawen]

Oh dear...the Day's ending!

Sorry about that, fellow villagers...I was swamped with schoolwork and more schoolwork and couldn't give heed to the more pressing need to save our village. Please let me go back through the discussions before I cast my vote. I surely wouldn't want voting for an innocent toDay, but the odds are against me...well, must do my best. For our prophet!

I'll be back.

[dancing spawn of ungoliant]

Three pages... *sigh*

I'll be back soon.

[Thinlómien]

I'm here and will leave in ten minutes. And I'm not sure if I wish to save Garin.

[Anguirel]

Just don't vote against the poor madman, alright? My forest instincts tell me that that way lies a grievous mistake. Wolf-Garin is much more in control and would never vote for himself anyway...

And then my axe naturally wings to the defence of the underdog...

[Thinlómien]

I might be able to come back before the voting time (I have a lesson in computer classroom) but I wouldn't count on it.

I'm not sure if I'm going to vote one of my feeble suspects or someone to save Garin. However, all the people in your (Ang's) list I hold as suspicious as Garin, some even less. I don't know if it's a bad thing that Garin goes. He might be a wolf.

EDIT: x-posted with Ang

[dancing spawn of ungoliant]

Well, I don't find any of those with the most votes very suspicious now. I shall take a moment to ponder the voting.

Cailín's vote is based on occupations. Can't tell much of it.

TGWBS' vote is based on occupations. Can't tell much of it.

Garin votes for himself in order to honour Nilp. I have no idea why he does that because later he says: "I am actually not sure what came over me, I've always held the suicidal with great contempt." A bluff? In any case, that's not very helpful a thing to do.

Lalaith votes TGWBS because he had suggested that people would do that. A somewhat safe vote which could be regarded as suspicious because her vote is based on occupations. "This copy-cat suicide outbreak seems very odd to me, anyhow." ~Lalaith

Eomer's vote is based on some master plan that I don't have time to try to understand now, so I can't tell much of it.

Kath's vote seems somewhat weird.

Originally Posted by Kath

Because (though I think this is repeating a past argument) if he's a wolf then better to get rid of him now, and if he's an innocent we won't be worrying about whether he's a wolf for the rest of the game! A hedging your bets argument it is I'll admit, but it's all I have.

As she admits, she repeats almost exactly the same words as tar-a in her past life. That reasoning got her in a bit of trouble then, but she turned out to be an innocent. Something in Kath's voting feels funny especially because if Eomer is innocent, it's good to keep him around.

tar-a's vote is probably one of the best reasoned toDay although I disagree with her.

Eonwe... Well... "I'm voting Garin and for no other reason than his placement on the list. Ha!" "The funny thing is, I started this bandwagon! Ha!" ~Eonwe
Right. I don't know why he's so cheerful and wants the 'credit' of the Garin 'bandwagon' for himself. Anyway, his reasons aren't very impressive.

Celuien's vote is reasoned, too. Doesn't look suspicious.

lmp's vote for Eomer may be a bit better reasoned than Kath's, but I don't know what to think of the fact that Eomer and lmp voted for each other like that. Maybe it's part of the 'master plan' that I didn't get yet.

Glirdan first had some kind of debate with Garin, but I'm not sure if the debate is the reason for his vote. "Well, the votes are spread to say the least, but I'm afraid that Garin's probably right, his fate is sealed. However, there is still a lot of other people who have yet to vote, so I'm probably wrong on this." ~Glirdan
I don't know what to think of this, but otherwise he has been acting like I would have assumed.

Farael votes for Anguirel because he thinks that Anguirel is a wolf faking to be a Seer? Farael's acting like I would have assumed, too, although I disagree with him. In any case, Happy Birthday!

Naria's behaviour seems typical for her although I don't like it. A safe vote with practically no reasons at all.

Caranlondien gives reasons for her vote. Good. Doesn't appear suspicious now.

Valier says that she votes for Glirdan because he seems most suspicious to her toDay, but she doesn't really give reasons why. Can't tell much of this vote.

I shall vote in a few minutes.

[Thinlómien]

Reading the thread through took me half an hour so I won't have much time to discuss.

I was very inclined to think Garin as a wolf, but after considering it a bit, I won't say so. If he was a newbie, I would say he's a wolf. But being that experienced as he is, I won't say so. He should be able to see the foolishness of his acts. But, on the other hand why would an ordo use the tactic? To get attention and not to get bored, maybe a bit disappointed about being ordo. A seer? A seer wouldn't risk himself knowing he's important to the village. Same goes with ranger. They are more responsible. A lover? Why would he want to try doom not only himself, but his precious lover too? Not likely. So either Garin is a wolf or a lover playing dangerously to get himself out of suspicion or then he is an villager trying to amuse himself.

(This is my posting style, Form, I can tell you: considering all sides off the issues I call it, those who doubt me call it flip-floppy.)

EDIT: xposted with Lhuna, though that doesn't probably matter

[Anguirel]

Well. Thank goodness I got up early to cast a vote at a very late stage.

Hmmm. Garin, whether innocent or guilty, is being lynched, not for any cogent reason, but because he's Garin. I'd really rather not have that. Village of fools!

But the other feasible options seem to be the suicidal Guy-again, folly-or possibly me, or Eomer.

I'd like to vote for Glirdan because the ermine lords of the forest paths tell me he just acted in a very obvious way to seal Garin's fate. But again, I don't think it's feasible.

Lhuna and Thinlomien-are you about? We must all vote together if we wish to save Garin.