Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVII: The Saga Continues to Continue quite Continuously

[Gil-Galad]

yeah i probably won't be able to get on, so i'm voting now



++Kath

[The Saucepan Man]

Well, my plan is clearly not going to work.

I guess that we shall just have to see where we are towards the close of the day tomorrow. I shall try to hold my vote until near the end of the day, but I can't guarantee anything. And I guess you can't trust me 100% either.

OK, so who do I think we should lynch today? I stand by what I said towards the end of the day yesterday concerning the four unknowns (so go back and read my contributions here and here if you want to know).

The only thing that I would add is I think it more likely that Gil-Galad didn't bother to read much of what had been said before he voted yesterday, rather than his vote being some elaborate double-bluff. As such, I am inclined to view him, for now at least, as innocent (although still a possible Cobbler). If he is a Wolf, he deserves to win for being so convincingly naive ...

I also have a serious nagging doubt about spawn. While TGWBS went out of his way to put the case for Kath's innocence, he said very little about spawn. He only really mentioned her among groups of other people, for example when he expressed the view that none of those who voted for Abercrombie were likely to be Wolves. Now, we all know TGWBS to be a subtle and crafty Wolf. I tend to think that this would be more his style when trying to clear a fellow Wolf.

Plus the fact that spawn has never really attracted serious supicion still concerns me. We have been notably bad at catching Wolves in this village. We would probably never have suspected TGWBS had it not been for malkatoj. I can well imagine that the other Wolf has been equally as slippery. And dancing spawn is more than capable of carrying it off.

As matters stand, I would be inclined to lynch spawn and Kath.

[Glirdan]

And I guess you can't trust me 100% either.

On the contrary my friend. I now trust you completely. I'm quite sorry for attacking you so ferociously at the beginning, but, that's what this is all about, right?

And I must also agree with you on the matter of Gil. I don't think that two Wolves would have been so quiet.

Now I must also say that Spawn and Kath are both unnerving me. They post enough, yet just barely enough to stay out of suspicion. I believe, just as you Saucy, that we should concentrate on these two. Garin is probably, as he ha been saying for quite some time now, just been framed by the Wolves. Gil is probably either the Cobbler or just a very confused villager.

So, what do we do from here?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

I rather doubt you are the Cobbler, Sauce. So I think the last vote can be yours--if you can do a holding pattern 'til the end of the DAY, that is.

And yes, that means I agree with the double-lynch. I mean, crikey, I was the one who first suggested it!

So, is it Kath and spawn, then? I trust spawn to be innocent, if that helps.

Garin looks innocent to me, but I'm not very sure. Gil-galad is very confusing, and has succeeded in avoiding serious suspicion so far. Since most of us thought that the Werewolves's plan is to have the loudmouths kill off each other, I think he's a perfect Werewolf.

Glirdan, you really are the Hunter? I knew I still got it.

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

I just noticed that I am persistent in defending spawn. Does that make me the Cobbler?

[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Glirdan

So, what do we do from here?

Can you hold your vote until later in the day? That would be the best thing. If not, I suggest that you vote for spawn, to give Kath and spawn one vote each.

Originally Posted by Nilp

I rather doubt you are the Cobbler, Sauce.

The feeling is mutual, my dear fellow.

Originally Posted by Nilp

I just noticed that I am persistent in defending spawn. Does that make me the Cobbler?

So no, it doesn't. But do you have any particular reason (other than personal ) for believing spawn to be innocent? If so, please declare it as, while I am not convinced that she is a Wolf (I am not convinced about anyone), she is high in my suspicions at the moment, for the reasons that I have given.

[Glirdan]

Can you hold your vote until later in the day? That would be the best thing. If not, I suggest that you vote for spawn, to give Kath and spawn one vote each.

I will try and hold off, but I may have to vote very soon. Don't worry though, I will take your advice and vote for spawn. I blieve that this plan of yours will actually work out my firend. I believe it will.

Nilp, I have not even come close to suspecting you. If anything, you've confused me this entire time. However, if anyone is the Cobbler, I don't think it's you. If it's anyone, I think it would be Form or Gil.

Now, I really wish someone else would say something other than us three. It's really unnerving me even though five of us are proven innocent.

[mormegil]

Sorry I've been very busy today. For what it's worth the double lynching idea makes sense to me and I think I will be able to vote late as it is a time that works fairly well for me. For my own opinion Kath is one that should go and possibly Gil. I just don't feel good about him and his vote yesterday, while explained, still seems odd enough.

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

But do you have any particular reason (other than personal ) for believing spawn to be innocent? If so, please declare it . . . (SpM)

Because she wouldn't lie to me. (I hope . . . )

Enedwaith, about the Cobbler, if he's among the innocent, we don't care. If he somehow ends up in revealing himself, he's toast, we ignore him, but we don't have to kill him. If he or she is among the unknowns, he or she will die enedwaith, so why worry?

Yeah, the Cobbler can screw the voting up. So can the last Werewolf. But I think if they have the gall to do that toDAY, then woohoo! They're dead tomorrow!

Hey, vy ze vay, if Kath is the last Werewolf, how come we're getting kills? I mean, she's off in Iceland since the 10th, right?

[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Nilp

Because she wouldn't lie to me.

Now surely you know her better than that ...

Am I to take it that this is your only reason for not suspecting spawn?

Originally Posted by Nilp

Hey, vy ze vay, if Kath is the last Werewolf, how come we're getting kills? I mean, she's off in Iceland since the 10th, right?

Good point, but she only said that she would be away for Day 5. And, even if she is away, I am sure that (if she is a Wolf) there are ways and means.