Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVII: The Saga Continues to Continue quite Continuously

[dancing spawn of ungoliant]

I'm finally back, sorry it took so long, but I just couldn't decide whether to match the flower arrangement to Menel's light brown hair or his bloodstained body.

Now, there has been a lot of talk of Wayne, Gil and Valier. Perhaps we should agree on a policy, how to treat villagers who are confusing and don't contribute as much as we should like so we didn't have to go it through every time.
Maybe we should think what are the pros and cons of lynching one of them? Well, if they are wolves, it's quite obvious that it benefits us, but let's take a look at the option that they aren't.

Pros: We don't have to ponder their identities later and we can concentrate on people who have talked more i.e. left more clues. Also, as everybody probably knows, they are easy targets, so it should be interesting to analyze the voting next day, and see if people really had a reason to go against them or did they just go with the majority hoping they could blend in.

Cons: We lose an innocent vote.

If you have something else to add to the list, please share your thoughts.

Well, I am slightly inclined towards Abercrombie but the coin tells me to vote for Valier

Ahem, are you a truffle hunter or a gambler? Just asking because I think it's a bit odd to decide whether someone will live or die by tossing a coin, especially if you're more inclined to vote the other one.

But what can we say about Abercrombie?

Well, many of seems to be in a rather light mood, cracking jokes and accusing each other with no reasons at all, but her actions are just a bit too weird for my liking. First she said that Formendacil's behaviour wasn't unusual, but then she randomly accuses him, Aiwendil and Gil demanding an explanation from them. However, after that she says that there is no evidence against them while pulling arguments "out of thin air". And then she says she doesn't really suspect Formendacil.
Umm, what!? Seems quite Cobblerish, but if Abercrombie were the Cobbler, I assume she'd be more subtle. But then again, you can never know.

Originally Posted by Abercrombie

++NILPAURION FELAGUND

I'm sorry if that's a random vote, but I'm afraid it's the best I can do.

If your best is to vote for someone who said he won't be here during the rest of the Day and who is a safe vote because the odds are that he won't be lynched today, I'd like to know what is your worst. Besides, you said you didn't want to vote for Wayne because he already had one vote. Why did you then want to vote for Nilp although he, too, had one vote? Young lady, you really are confusing me!

To honest, I'm really unsure whom I should vote for and alas, I have to vote in a few minutes or then I can't vote at all.