WWJ III - Nan Qualinmerë: Death Wish Valley

[Kath]

I am an innocent yet my personality will always be wolfish. It is an easy vote for a wolf to make without being suspected. I think either Ang or Aber or wolves, or even Roan, or Wayne or Kath...
See, it would be idiotic to say for sure who is a wolf but some have dared to do so.

But Garin you aren't giving us reasons why! If you would just tell us the reasoning behind these thoughts then maybe we would see the same things you do. The way you're reacting right now is the same as the way Shelob reacted last night, and look what happened to her! You're against suicide, ok, we got that, but the way you're behaving is guaranteed to get you killed!

Please, just give us some reasons!

[Garin]

I am going on instinct, human instinct. Aber has cast votes against me and I know I am innocent. I suspect her due to her voting record and her knowingly targeting an innocent villager. Shelob has taught us a lesson that I have a problem learning. Perhaps, my death will bring us closer to the true wolves. Ang still disturbs me but must be a most masterful wolf if he is one.

[Kath]

I suspect her due to her voting record and her knowingly targeting an innocent villager.

Knowingly targeting an innocent villager? Knowingly? Which innocent would this be Garin, how would she know unless she were a wolf, which as you say yourself she cannot be certain of. And anyway, she isn't the only one. Many others, including you yourself, did so. It was widely believed yesterday that Shelob was guilty, because of the way she was acting. Get yourself out of this snit Garin, or it looks like you'll find yourself going the same way.

[Garin]

That innocent villager happens to be me not Shelob.
Edit: Thus is the reason I am voting for her.

[Kath]

Then Garin, it is unknowingly.

++GARIN

I have to go, and nothing you have said has eased my suspicion of you. I just hope you don't turn out to be another Shelob.

[Garin]

I just hope you don't turn out to be another Shelob.

I will be. Sorry fellow ordinaries.
By 'knowingly' it would mean to say that I believe Abercrombie to be a wolf. Hence, my vote for her.

[Valesse]

By 'knowingly' it would mean to say that I believe Abercrombie to be a wolf. Hence, my vote for her.

I may be half starved and have no backbone, but I'm not dumb. Tar was our seer, and that means none of us can know who the others are for sure UNLESS they are also wolf.

I could suspect Abers if I knew how long (or how short) your experiances are with this game, but since I am without this knowledge I can only vex myself and practice a series of one handed cartwheels on a balance beam until my brain starts to bleed.

Other than that I really don't know who to vote for tomorrow. When it comes (assuming that I wake) I'll have to reread the entire thread. ... Up-side-down... with a china cup on my head. Anyway, since votes are already being cast I'll just go ahead and do it since the accussed seems too tired to think up something forthcoming.

++ Garin

[Valesse]

No one has given me a good enough reason for Wayne and Gandalf.

Wayne was with me all night practicing while I was dreaming of Gandalf... but lets just keep that between you, me, and the fly on the wall. Thank goodness Mejis doesn't have a town gossip!

Actually their behavior is funny. By voting for each other they are partial and not attractive to our focus... after all... they aren't voting for -us-, and thats when everyone really gets nervous, isn't it? It could easily be a distractionary tactic unlike one I have see before or perhaps many of us... but we noticed it.

If we're ever able to catch either online a good questioning is in order, I'd say.

Other than that... who are we to defend them? We don't know who they truely are... and why do we have to tell you, Garin? Do you know something about one of them and are jealously seething over his seeming invisiblity... Or are you quizzing us? More likely just trying to divert our attention.