The Greatest of the Eldar

[Maédhros]

Luthien was the greatest of the Eldar. Discussion over.

Ah, but the question is the greatest in what?
Was she the greatest craftmen of the Eldar? I think not.

If you are going by the opinion of the Lord of the Valar or the Eldar themselves, it's Ingwë.

Oh, please. The Valar in their history had made many mistakes, and i wouldn´t take the choice of Ingwë into consideration for the greatest. After all, were was he in the war of Wrath. He was in Valinor under the protection of the Valar, instead of in ME were his people were fighting.