The Hobbit Survivor

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

The whole buisness about voting off dead dwarves before the living ones is nonsence. We must either see all the dwarves (and other beeings) as living or dead.

It would not make sence to make a surviver show with dead people!

If Thrain is dead then why Is the trolls William and Tom not? We are told how they die in the Hobbit. Allso did we not assume that Aragorn was living in LOTR Surviver, but his death is allso told to us.

The only way that SPM and other fanatics can make a case against this is if all that we are told is somthing that is foreseen and has not yet taken place, but it is not so this is "history" and therefor everybody (exept the elves) is dead! get it? THEY ARE DEAD! ! !

And since it would be silly to have alot of dead people lying on an island and voting each other off it. (how would they do that) Then lets take it for grantet that they are all alive. How they are brought back to life I care not about, use a time warp or what ever you fancy.

[Anguirel]

Hear hear!

This thing about people being dead and smelling, started as a quip of Formendacil's I believe, is really no longer funny or clever. I mean, it never was that funny or clever, but now it's about as funny and clever as Old Tom Bombadillo.

[Elu Ancalime]

Actually I was thinking along Rune's idea the whole time: What year is the Survivor taking place? Otherwise dead is irrelevant. I was just to slow and lazy to post it.

Therefore, seeing as that idea is not alone,

--Thrain, ++Thrain

That makes no sense you say. I Still vote for Thrain, but on different reasoning.
________
Honda Rafaga history

[Lalaith]

My dear Kuru, with regard to your proposal, I am open to all kinds of suggestions but none which would involve the demise of Beorn.
If you've got any better offers I'll be delighted to consider them.

[Anguirel]

My offer (assuming Dori is among those who are evicted today) is to continue the fine, traditional Elf sport, Dwarf-hunting.

I'd like to target Balin but I'm willing to compromise to Gloin, Bombur, Fil or Kili...

[Lalaith]

Ok, Ang, here's an idea, you stay away from Balin and Beorn, and I'll back you on one of the other dwarves.

[Lalaith]

PS - I never had you down as a troll-lover...