Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

[Farael]

Originally Posted by Meneltarmacil

As for Lhuna, I'm not sure what to make of her. Her vote for him, as someone has said, does fit her usual voting pattern. The possibility does exist that she is a Wolf, though. I'm very uncertain about her right now.

My suggestion is this: Lynch Nilpaurion Felagund toDay, while having the Seer ask Garin whether Lhuna's a wolf during the Night.

Cross-posted with Menel and Lhuna... could someone please review last day's voting? I don't trust myself for that task, I'm afraid and I think we are sticking too much to the first day's voting while more clues could be found on the second day... if what I said on my last post is right, we might be better off looking away from Lhuna (as Garin voted for her, bringing her "score" up to a tie with him) and away from Gurthang who seemed to have sealed Garin's destiny.

And why did I quote Menel? well, how are we going to know what the Seer finds out? unless he/she knows a werewolf already, he/she should remain silent I think. Although if the seer knows a wolf, he/she should talk immediately as we can lynch the wolf today, have the apprentice ask him tonight about someone else and we would know a couple of innocents assuming:
-The Seer asked about two persons to Moderacil
-The Seer asked about someone else to Garin
-The Seer is obviously not a wolf
That would take four people out of the question, and as I only support the seer coming forward if he knows for sure about a wolf, that'd mean we get rid of another wolf and get four confirmed innocents. I think it's a fair bargain, don't you? furthermore, the Ranger can still protect the seer one more night (assuming he protected him last night and not someone else)