Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

[Azaelia of Willowbottom]

I agree with others, for reasons already stated, that Nilp is probably someone we should be looking at. His interactions with Garin are interesting enough to beg further discussion.

It seems to me that they knew each other in more than just passing, from the way they were interacting, and I think it's more than fairly possible that Garin was waiting to see if Nilp needed saving...His comment at the time about waiting to see if he was going to be lynched was strange since he seemed to be in no immediate danger. In the context of the vote depending on Nilp needing saving, I think it makes sense.

Now that we know Garin was a wolf, I am more willing to let my suspicion of Valier go...they wouldn't have had that dispute if both were wolves, it looks to me like too much of a gamble.

TGWBS also makes me nervous, though not so nervous as Nilp...His lack of input seems rather uncharacteristic, which worries me. However, it could be that there are circumstances in RL that we don't know about, so I'll let him slide by for just a little while longer before I start really wondering about him. Innocent until proven guilty, and silence alone is not enough to condemn someone.

I'd also like to know who needed the protection last night. It's an interesting turn of events.