Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

[Kuruharan]

This list was compiled after post 205, so it is probably a little dated now.

Alcarillo - Cailín post 163
Lhunardawen – Eluchil post 168
Amanaduial – Lhunardawen post 169
Nilpaurion – Cailín post 172
Farael – Garin post 195
malkatoj – Lhunardawen post 196
Rune – Garin post 200
TGWBS – Lhunardawen post 204

Totals
Cailín-2
Eluchil-1
Lhunardawen-3
Garin-2

(Somebody please correct me if I’ve made a mistake.)

With regard to Meneltarmacil’s argument against Lhuna, I’m uncomfortable building a case on how people react to Nilp. That is why (at this moment) I don’t care for the idea of lynching Lhuna. Nilp’s so strange that he beggars rational reaction. Even if we lynch him and he proves to be a wolf, I’m not entirely sure we could tie him securely to anybody else (which sounds like a darn good werewolf strategy, now that I mention it.)

At this moment I’m not sure I want to inject another candidate into the mix. We’ve already got four with votes and a possible fifth. Whatever happens, I don’t think we want more than one person to be lynched and if the voting stays close that could happen.

Cailín-I’m not particularly suspicious of her myself. Unfortunately, I can’t think of a real reason for this. If she is lynched, we might learn a bit.

Eluchil-Has largely managed to avoid notice. That worries me.

Lhunardawen-I don’t particularly want her to be lynched today. I don’t find the case against her compelling. She wasn’t the only one to vote against Nilp yesterday…

Garin- I’ve always been suspicious of Garin. He’s always seemed a bit crafty to me. That makes me nervous. If I vote for one of these four, he’d be the one I’d vote for.

EDIT: Surprise, surprise, surprise. Nobody else had voted after all.