Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Cailín · 01-12-2006, 08:52 AM

How peculiar, it seems like you have to vote for yourself to avoid suspicion in this village. It is strange how Nilpaurion has suddenly lost all desire to murder himself – he hardly even tries to look suspicious anymore and is currently under most people’s radar. Rather ironic if he should turn out to be a very bold wolf who has developed the perfect strategy to elude suspicion.

Also, I start to see Lhuna and Nilp’s point and am reconsidering the wisdom of other people and me voting for Gil yesterday. He had left already and little chance of defending himself, and with the current werewolf / gifted / ordo ratio, we are pretty darn lucky he turned out to be an innocent. We could have easily killed our Seer or Apprentice: there was slight evidence against Gil (yes, his vote was not brilliant, but he seemed to be in a hurry) and the only reason I preferred him dangling on the noose yesterday was because I was inclined to (not) trust Nilp and he generally offers (as he has shown today) somewhat better and especially more extended insights.

Though I hate accusing anyone voting for me, because people think you’re ‘touchy’ when doing that, I have certain doubts concerning Alcarillo as well. He was quick to vote both yesterday and today, did not really participate in discussions to avoid suspicion and has cast a vote for me with very little reasoning (though I cannot guarantee I am fully objective when it concerns something as precious to me as my own life).

I think Garin has made some valid points about Valier in his post above, so I shall not repeat them here.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Threaded Mode

01-12-2006, 08:52 AM	#11
Cailín Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Lurking in the shadows. Posts: 711	How peculiar, it seems like you have to vote for yourself to avoid suspicion in this village. It is strange how Nilpaurion has suddenly lost all desire to murder himself – he hardly even tries to look suspicious anymore and is currently under most people’s radar. Rather ironic if he should turn out to be a very bold wolf who has developed the perfect strategy to elude suspicion. Also, I start to see Lhuna and Nilp’s point and am reconsidering the wisdom of other people and me voting for Gil yesterday. He had left already and little chance of defending himself, and with the current werewolf / gifted / ordo ratio, we are pretty darn lucky he turned out to be an innocent. We could have easily killed our Seer or Apprentice: there was slight evidence against Gil (yes, his vote was not brilliant, but he seemed to be in a hurry) and the only reason I preferred him dangling on the noose yesterday was because I was inclined to (not) trust Nilp and he generally offers (as he has shown today) somewhat better and especially more extended insights. Though I hate accusing anyone voting for me, because people think you’re ‘touchy’ when doing that, I have certain doubts concerning Alcarillo as well. He was quick to vote both yesterday and today, did not really participate in discussions to avoid suspicion and has cast a vote for me with very little reasoning (though I cannot guarantee I am fully objective when it concerns something as precious to me as my own life). I think Garin has made some valid points about Valier in his post above, so I shall not repeat them here.