Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIV: Nyárë Nauroron Númenoreva

[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Gurthang

I am really surprised that my plan was that close to working completely as I had hoped. To think, if you had just chosen me instead of Jack, then this just might have been the shortest game ever.

Now, just hold on there just one cotton pickin' moment, Gurthang me lad, before you carry on yer crowin'.

First, I doubt that I am alone in having regarded your behaviour throughout the two days you were with us as highly suspicious. You may have had a plan, but you can hardly blame us for lynching you in light of what you said and did. I was actually beginning to think you genuine towards the end of day 2, but I supported Morm's double lynch plan because you were just so darn confusin'.

And secondly, the Wolves may have been taken in by your Seer act, but I did not think for one moment that you might actually be the Seer. Your behaviour, drawing so much attention to you as it did, was just too un-Seer-like. The only possibility was that you were a Seer playing un-Seer-like on purpose, but you pretty much dismissed that idea in my head when you first raised the possibility that you might be the Seer, then admitted that you were protecting the Seer and then tried to make out you were the Seer again.

'Twas undoubtedly a noble plan, executed with worthy intention, but it was flawed. Not least because (as Holby cleverly and seemingly innocently) pointed out, you risked drawing the Ranger's protection away from the Seer and leaving her exposed (a risk that, as it turned out, bacame a reality).

Originally Posted by Folwren

I'm really sorry for having died that second night. I didn't mean to be too obvious.

No need to be hard on yourself, Folwren. I didn't pick up on the clues until I reviewed your posts at the start of day 2 in the knowledge that you were the Seer. And it seems that the Wolves didn't pick up on them either. You were chosen by the Wolves not because they thought you were the Seer but because they thought that the Ranger would be protecting the person who they actually thought was the Seer (namely, wannabe Seer Gurthang ).

Originally Posted by Folwren

Unforuntaely, I still failed to leave enough prove behind to keep you alive.

Again, I see no fault on your part here. I thought that it was pretty clear from what you said that you had dreamed of me. You cannot imagine how frustrating it was when people suddenly started changing their minds and deciding that you hadn't dreamed of me after all (*coughBorocough*) ...