Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIV: Nyárë Nauroron Númenoreva

[Formendacil]

Originally Posted by Fordim Hedgethistle

Formendacil: 3, 4.4 (2)

I'm quite flattered, my dear Fordhim that you think me dangerous if a wolf... Mind you, you missed the last game when I was a wolf, and botched it from Day 1, but is a flattering thought... Misguided, of course, but anyone would say that about themselves.

As for the 4.4 charge, I must confess to being guilty on that score. The heavier pressures of actually having a job and the rush of the dreaded pre-Christmas season have fallen up me... but still, that's no excuse I suppose for a mariner Numenorean in a Vala-forsaken fishing village.

Originally Posted by Gurthang

And now Formendacil has added to my suspicion. He posted about three people, yet just listed possibilities, never telling which he thought. Just this or that, not very helpful to me.

What if my mind is undecided? I mean, really... if the evidence says that all of these three could be Werewolves, but quite possible aren't, then shouldn't I trust my own logic and feelings on that matter? This isn't Day 1 anymore, and there is no reason for random voting, unless I am the Cobbler and have a death wish...

And speaking of Cobblers, the temptation to vote for you, my dear Gurthang, is great, and the spirit is weak, so I shall...

Here's my reasoning: I really have no clue who the Werewolves are. There are several suspicious-looking people, but nobody who actually screams "WEREWOLF" to me. We do, however, have someone who screams "COBBLER!".

I am speaking of Gurthang, of course. His actions yesterday, and moreso today, have been very Cobblerish. And although the Cobbler is not, in and of itself, dangerous as a Werewolf is, he (or she!) is a confusing player, and just as well gotten rid of if we want to flush out the real Werewolves- which we do.

For this reason, Gurthang should, in my opinion, be voted off. Whether he is the Cobbler or not is almost immaterial, since the facts are that he has been acting a good deal like one.

And yes, I do realise that between his vote on Day 1 and his accusation against me today this may look a little like revenge. So what? Don't YOU want to kill the Werewolves' team?

++Gurthang