Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIII: Enter Shamville

[Kitanna]

Originally Posted by Firefoot

Even though I was extremely suspicious of Wayne for his desire for a double vote, I think that he may be the innocent one in this.

I must disagree. You of course make good points against Wilwa as seer, but I still think she is innocent. You say her fashion of coming out as the seer is not something a real seer would do and that it is rather stupid and Wilwa is not stupid. Wilwa isn't stupid by a longshot of course which is what makes me think she is still innocent despite her role.

Her coming out as seer is a very foolish move if she's a wolf and Wilwa should know that. Doing something like that draws so much attention and then when her "wolf" is lynched and proved innocent everyone knows, the real seer has probably dreamt of her and is going to rat her out and the seer-wolf loses and a good chance comes about that the team will be discovered and they would lose. The wolves don't want that. Wilwa as a wolf and saying she is the seer seems far too stupid a plan for the wolves to try to establish.

In any case out of the two I find Wilwa more innocent than Wayne. And we should probably vote for one or the other today.