The Silmarillion Survivor

[Anguirel]

Originally Posted by Gothmog

Oh, I feel this is going the usual way, which means not my way... Don't you see how easy that mod is manipulating you? You even think it's your own idea! There's a man worthy of replacing Sauron after a new Dark Lord has claimed the throne (if that'll be the case).

Lalaith:

So true! So why don't you break free from the chains he's created for you?

By his sweet (but poisonous, believe me) words and pulling of strings, he'll put an end to all of ME with Melkor ruling as supreme king with Curufin at his right hand!

My plan revealed! But you forgot a few things. Such as Maeglin happily married to Idril and King of Gondolin; Celegorm married to Luthien...Maglor, Daeron and Salgant forming a band...

Originally Posted by Gothmog

No, people, wake up and realize what your doing! Voting for Turgon, one of the great elven kings, one of those with armies great enough to challenge the host of Angband. Too long did he hide in his city, I'm not going to deny that, but when he finally came, he did it in the right time. Nirnaeth Arnoediad, tears unnumbered, was a catastrophy but what if Turgon hadn't showed up? What had been left of elven, man or dwarfen kind then?

Gondolin and her armies can exist without Turgon. We don't hear of Turgon doing anything in the Nirnaeth except turning up and running away leaving the humans to die. Maeglin, on the other hand, "proved fell and fearless in battle"-obviously a superior general, equipped, though I say it myself, with the most powerful sword in Middle-earth...

Originally Posted by Gothmog

In what way is Idril better at stopping the ravaging than her father? And to stop it is the task we've been given.

No hard feeling, Ang

Ooo! Get him, Lalaith!

And Gothmog, I am far from offended. That was one of the most flattering posts I've ever read, in fact...

VOTES

Sauron-1
Morgoth-3
Turgon-3