The Silmarillion Survivor

[Gothmog]

the Phantom:

As long as Melkor's got the jewels, the oath is great because it will ensure that the Sons of Feanor will oppose Melkor to the death, and if the eldest of the sons is king then everyone will follow in unity.

Yes, but I'm afraid it will also ensure that the sons of Feanor oppose Melkor to the death of 99% of the other elves. But true is that if the eldest son is chosen, there'll be less complaining. So why choose Curufin? No, go for Fingolfin or Maedhros. It's your choice, I'll stick with Fingolfin.

I really do hope that, as some people seem so confident about, the sons of Feanor will get an other kind of life without the kinslaying. I don't think that will save Curufin though... I'm afraid he's lost and has to go before he makes something stupid.

(Yikes! I got into a sig! Never thought that day would come Thanks Anguirel...I think...)