Tol-in-Gaurhoth (Isle of Werewolves)

[Boromir88]

Trying this new Hunter role would be rather interesting.

I think it shouldn't be a daily thing, because with few players the game could go really really fast. I think mormegil brings up good points to favor it. You get one a game, and it would have to be a decisive, wise, decision at a crucial point in the game that could either make or break the villagers.

I think having the Hunter kill someone daily would just be too fast for my liking, and creates too many kills in one day/night phase.

Phantom said this was going to be a small game...I'm guess 16-17 people? With about 3 kills a day (the lynching, then the hunter and wolf kills- if the Ranger doesn't intervene) it will go by in under a week. I think if we are to try this "new Hunter" it should be a once in a game thing. Of course, he still gets to choose who dies with him daily.

Doesn't matter though, it sounds interesting and worth trying, but I would be in favor of keeping the hunter the way he is as well.