Ring driven or Meat Driven?

[Lily Bombadil]

Boromir88, but if we've read the books, we knew Pippin didn't have the Ring. If they'd put Grishnak's Ring-driven-ness in the movie, it still would've built up the suspense of wondering what would happen to Merry and Pippin. I personally would like to have seen Grishnak portrayed by the book. It definitely would've been nice to see more Tolkien and more cleverness in the movie. But then I guess PJ's chased-through-the-woods thing would've been out? I can't really say. Sometimes the things PJ does, brilliant though he is, end in utter stupidity and disaster... Gotta love PJ...