Tolkien is Not Yeats

[Purple Monkey]

Welcome to the Downs, Purple Monkey.

Why, thank you dearie. [img]smilies/biggrin.gif[/img] You know, I've been at the forum for a month or so and no welcome came my way! Many "That's stupid" and "Shut up"s though. [img]smilies/wink.gif[/img]

I think that the critic should have probably taken into account that, in the timeframe that LotR was set in, Pip's song would have been considered very fashionable indeed! In fact, probably as fashionable as us belting out Christina Aguilera in the shower. I'm sure no-one here does that though, what with all the dignity.

Purple "Gonna get dirrty - someday" Monkey