The importance of intelligent debate

[narfforc]

Does anyone remember the the Argument sketch from Monty Pythons. If we open an Argument thread, then that will keep those who just like to say the opposite, happy. Just feed it junk and watch what happens. I do jest by the way. For many parts of Tolkiens works there are many different view points and interpretations. Look at what has happened to religion, will we have wars in the future between Balrog Wingers and Non-Wingers, shall we descend into reading from great volumes of Tolkien Dictionaries, denouncing unbelievers to be burned at the stake. I suggest you read what posters have to say, gesticulate at your screen or laugh your head off, then write a calm respectful response, telling how your views differ. I myself think there is a Man in the Moon, WHY? because Tolkien says there was, and I will hear no heretic say different.

[Lathriel]

Wow! Another great thread that should be required reading for Newbies, especially the post by Estelyn Telcontar. As with some of the other threads regarding 'expected vs observed' behavior, I see myself pre-humously (the opposite of post-humously) 'mentioned' in the various posts, having violated various rules, bylaws and etiquette - I'm actually fearful of posting again...

Amen to that

I myself keep from name calling because I think its extremely childish!However, I also am guilty from posting due to rising emotions and sometimes I get quite hotheaded myself.

I also think that dumbing it down is an intelligent thread and I enjoy reading that one. Sometimes I feel my temper beginning ot flare when I read it though and some posts posted by fellow BDers are a bit heated and get close to name calling although the thread hasn't degrated to that yet. (Thank goodness)