The Link between Tolkien, Peter Pan, and Star Wars...

[Bungo Baggins]

I think it is natural that people who are attracted to Tolkien's works usually like Star Wars, Peter Pan, Narnia, the classic Sinbad movies, etc. These types of fans are appreciative of imaginative worlds. However, I think if a survey were taken, most Tolkien fans would place his works high above the others. They are all great stories but it would be like comparing a hamburger at McDonalds to a gourmet French meal. i.e. Tolkien has much more substance and depth.

Peter Pan will certanly always be around (and is popular now because of teen idol Jeremy Sumpter and the fantastic new Johnny Depp movie), as will Star wars and other classic stories. But I think people looking for a deeper literary experience will always appreciate Tolkien. He not only created a great story (as did the others) but created an entire world, language and history. The Star Wars movies will be remembered fondly by people who grew up with the original, but the latest three will not have the same legions of fans as were drawn to Jackson's movies.

Tolkien's genius aside, the people who appreciate his works are more likely to enjoy Peter Pan, Narnia, Incredibles, King Kong, etc. than the crowd who would rather see something like a Woody Allen movie.