If you could have.....

[THE Ka]

Originally Posted by Shy Hobbit

Well, if we put aside all gender restrictions, I would have loved to be Boromir, simply because he's such an emotionaly complex and interesting character.

Of course, I would have probably been happy with random hobbit/elf/rohirrim, etc

Yes! Finally, someone understands! put ALL gender restrictions away! lock them in a heavly locked closet! And, that is exactly WHY i would choose to play Boromir, the emotional complexity! always changing, new plots and turns! or you could say bi-polar... but not that in a bad way! I have asked my friend about this excluding all gender restrictions and the such, and she said that she would do anything to be a hobbit. When i asked her why, she said she had always wanted feet that large... strange reason? i think not. I asked her i could be her hobbit friend, but she replied that i was too much of an elf... that situation i cannot give you an answer that makes any sense... my friend is just like that. and that, for many reasons is why she's my friend.

[Meela]

I would like to have been Denethor. I want to understand him better.

If not Denethor, I suppose I'd make a good Eowyn, and an even better Faramir.

[Failivrin]

i would've been Faramir so i could have got a say in his lines and changed them.

Otherwise, Galadriel because i would be able to pronounce Earendil correctly and i think she was the female who kept most faithfully to the book.

Well, if we put aside all gender restrictions, I would have loved to be Boromir, simply because he's such an emotionaly complex and interesting character.

Ah yes, that's why I would've enjoyed being an Istar, most likely Gandalf or even Radagast.

Playing Glorfindel wouldn't be bad either, he's so overlooked.

[Elianna]

...Galadriel because i would be able to pronounce Earendil correctly...

hehehehe That bugs me so much.

Glorfindel.... he's so overlooked.

I say we start a Glorfindel fan club.

Gender aside, I would play...............Faramir, if I could be Book-Faramir, not Movie-Faramir.
In the movie, I guess I'd like to be..........Haldir: bow, Elvish, Galadriel, Helm's Deep, death scene...Yes, Haldir would be nice.

[THE Ka]

Originally Posted by Meela

I would like to have been Denethor. I want to understand him better.

If not Denethor, I suppose I'd make a good Eowyn, and an even better Faramir.

Hmm. Me as Boromir... (chuckle, chuckle.) I wouldn't mind having you as a father... just kidding! Besides, my hobbit-wanna-be friend said i'm too much of an elf anyway. In that case, if i was an elf, i would live in the Grey Haven... because i'm infatuated with the ocean. i think this is a fact since i am a serious Ictheofaegi ( Eater of fish...) Many other things i'm imfatuated with: deserts, ancient Egypt, golden bracelets, ABBA, being a scorpio, Octapus (eating it.), boats, Spongebob Squarepants, my laugh (which has been refered by a close friend as muderous), and many other stupid, useless talents I use and have... I think i've said too much... Okay, with that in mind, just ignore all the above useless junk of my life...

[The Only Real Estel]

If we're talking dream character I'd have liked to be Frodo, but if we're talking what I actually could've done with my raw acting skills, I'd have to settle for something considerably less ...like maybe an orc extra or something .

[Essex]

Like Fingolfin above, I would have loved to have been Aragorn, mainly because he gets to french kiss Liv Tyler. I also would have forced Jackson to make more of the eternal love triangle with Eoywn as well......

[Everdawn]

I would have been Éowyn. Just her strength of character is so empowering to her character. Her complexity would have made her a fantastic acting challenge.

[Elianna]

Essex:

I also would forced Jackson to make more of the eternal love triangle with Éowyn as well...

By this you mean you as Aragorn would kiss Miranda Otto too? boys...