Thinking ahead and/or being fooled

[Diamond18]

I was, however surprised about Frodo's fate and his voyage at the Grey Havens. Even though I sympathise what he was going through, I sometimes feel that he overreacted at times, feeling wiser and sorrier for himself than he really should have. Tell me if you agree, or if I am just being naive.

I agree, Bombadilo. I always thought that if Sam were the main Ring-bearer instead of Frodo, he could have endured and recovered better.

And merlilot, if I were Sam and had to face that choice...I might have pushed Frodo, but I definitely would have thrown myself in, too. [img]smilies/frown.gif[/img] But Sam, he could never kill Frodo, no matter what. Thank goodness for Gollum.

I also was fooled by Pippin being dead, and I almost threw the book across the room!

PS, Thanks Estelyn...I never thought you were an ogre, I just wasn't sure how "advanced" this topic was.