The Mirthies

[Thorongil]

I'll go with this:

~Best Overall Character~ Gandalf
~Best Female Character~ Galadriel
~Best Male Character~ Gandalf
~Best Cameo Appearance~ PJ
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Balrog
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir
~Best Battle~ Pellenor
~Best Maia~ Gandalf
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum
~Most missed character~ Glorfindel
~Best hairdo~ Legolas (don't really care about this, but I'll give Leggy one)
~Best supporting character~ Samwise Gamgee

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen
~Worst Male Character~ Legolas
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ
~Worst Overall Villain~ Gothmog
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Shelob
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor
~Worst Maia~ Sauron
~Worst Hairdo~ Haldir
~Worst dramatic scene~Faramir and Frodo squaring off over the one Ring
~Least missed chacter~ Tom Bombadil
~Worst supporting character~ Grima Wormtongue