Shelobe not in TTT!!

[Glenethor]

Hmmmm...I wonder. I think it is the most obvious thing in the world, to make the Shelob scene the cliffhanger. I guess PJ doesn't want to be obvious. The next best place to leave Frodo and Sam, I guess, is just as they leave the crossroads and enter into Morgul Vale. Then there is Aragorn, Gimli, and Legolas on the Paths of the Dead. If PJ holds to form, he won't do that as a flashback as it was when they are talking to Merry and Pip in the Houses of Healing. So, we may see that. Finally, there is the scene where the winged Nazgul approaches Isengard just after Pip looks into the Palantir. No one has asked PJ about the <I>Wraiths on Wings</I> making their appearance in TTT that I am aware of. Even Gandalf and Pip racing toward Minas Tirith would work, so I don't necessarily think that the actual closing scenes need be improvised.<p>[ February 27, 2002: Message edited by: Glenethor ]