101 reasons why Samwise Gamgee is evil!

[arianrod]

I have nothing against placing the characters in funny situations or laughing about something they did, but when you totally change the character and turn them into something they are not, such as certain comments made about Sam wanting to kill Frodo, or doing things to Frodo and Rosie, then I think that is rather disrespecful even to the fun side of LOTR.

I agree, Luthien. I think this 'discussion' is crossing the line, regardless of the lighthearted nature of Middle Earth Mirth. Basically, saying these things about such a wonderful character just isn't funny.