How do YOU deal out your bones?

[Telchar]

I rate! and Im proud to say that I use the full spectrum. I see alot of people saying: 'I usually either rate 1 or 5' hmmm my opinion to this is: This is the real world - I dont belive in pure evil or stupidity - neither in true uncompromised exelence (With Mithadan as a possible exception [img]smilies/wink.gif[/img] )
I try to judge people - some I have judge poorly (I must admit) some I have judged rightly. Here are some of the things that will earn a bones from me:

A Do you make sence in your posts?
B Do you at least try to make sence in your posts?
C Do your posts show that you have done any research on the topic?
D Do your posts have annything to contribute to The Downs? (relevance)
E Do you humor me/are your sarcastic comments well placed?
F Are you helpfull to others, at least to some degree
G Do you have a great storage of knowledge on the life of JRR Tolkien and his works?
H Do you try to give and take from The Downs? (good) .... or are you only here to see your own words on a webpage without concern of their relevance? (Bad)