Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[Aganzir]

The suggestion Lommy gave about Cab's death sounds plausible although I wouldn't rule out any other thing, either. And it's funny that my first reaction, too, was, "Ha! Nog's guilty!"
I don't see much sense in speculating who might have chosen him since it's possible to find a reason for just about everybody to have him as a kill.

Originally Posted by Boro

Anyway, long story short, my reaction was hasty, and I hope to continue to see you pursue your suspects aggressively, and to the point.

I don't like your suggestion that much. If I really suspect someone, I don't give up my suspicions, but I can suspect someone even if I don't pursue them aggressively. If you're a wolf this looks almost like mockery, "Keep suspecting innocents with such fury, mwa-ha-ha"!

Originally Posted by Lommy

No, it isn't outrageous, but I think there's a huge difference. I think a rep fails his/her responsibility if she doesn't vote, whil s/he only fails the wishes of those who voted for him/her if she votes against their wishes. A rep's duty is not to oblige his/her voters, but his/her duty IS to take the responsibility s/he's given.

Was phantom irresponsible and outrageous when he threw away his vote on Shasta? Are reps whose votes don't make a difference irresponsible? Why should a rep who votes no one be considered irresponsible if they are not?

Originally Posted by Lommy

Tsk, tsk, one step futher and it's putting words to people's mouths...

To be honest I don't think I was indicating you had said anything like it - I was rather taking the thought process one step further (also because I thought you could have thought so, too).

Originally Posted by Lommy

Although I don't really like Agan's smooth withdrawal from her suspicions against me at all

Why?

Originally Posted by Legate

Especially as her first suspecting Legate, then expressing surprise and maybe slight disapproval of the great (here we go again ) suddenly appeared suspicion against him and then voted him. That's what I'd call flip-flopping.

What I found weird was the seeming lack of reasoning behind people's suspicion; "Hey let's suspect him because others do it too!" Greenie said it was weird how Legate was lynched without any proper case against him and I think she's quite right. And I can admit I didn't have a real case, either.

edit: xed since Lommy