The suggestion
Lommy gave about
Cab's death sounds plausible although I wouldn't rule out any other thing, either. And it's funny that my first reaction, too, was, "Ha!
Nog's guilty!"

I don't see much sense in speculating who might have chosen him since it's possible to find a reason for just about everybody to have him as a kill.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boro
Anyway, long story short, my reaction was hasty, and I hope to continue to see you pursue your suspects aggressively, and to the point.
|
I don't like your suggestion that much. If I really suspect someone, I don't give up my suspicions, but I can suspect someone even if I don't pursue them aggressively. If you're a wolf this looks almost like mockery, "Keep suspecting innocents with such fury, mwa-ha-ha"!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lommy
No, it isn't outrageous, but I think there's a huge difference. I think a rep fails his/her responsibility if she doesn't vote, whil s/he only fails the wishes of those who voted for him/her if she votes against their wishes. A rep's duty is not to oblige his/her voters, but his/her duty IS to take the responsibility s/he's given.
|
Was phantom irresponsible and outrageous when he threw away his vote on Shasta? Are reps whose votes don't make a difference irresponsible? Why should a rep who votes no one be considered irresponsible if they are not?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lommy
Tsk, tsk, one step futher and it's putting words to people's mouths...
|
To be honest I don't think I was indicating you had said anything like it - I was rather taking the thought process one step further (also because I thought you could have thought so, too).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lommy
Although I don't really like Agan's smooth withdrawal from her suspicions against me at all
|
Why?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Legate
Especially as her first suspecting Legate, then expressing surprise and maybe slight disapproval of the great (here we go again ) suddenly appeared suspicion against him and then voted him. That's what I'd call flip-flopping.
|
What I found weird was the seeming lack of reasoning behind people's suspicion; "Hey let's suspect him because others do it too!"
Greenie said it was weird how
Legate was lynched without any proper case against him and I think she's quite right. And I can admit I didn't have a real case, either.
edit: xed since Lommy