WW XXXX - The scouring of the Shire, vol.2

[Brinniel]

Analysis of Lommy:

Day 1

#32: Thinks people shouldn't grumble about quiets- they leave trails too. Disagrees with Valier that loud players easily stay hidden. Finds Brinn slightly furry.

#36: Doesn't see what's so suspicious about Valier- she seems normal. Doesn't want to vote Green because she's a newbie. Finds Nerwen suspicious because of her comment about Rikae on Mac.

#47: Volo makes sense. Disagrees with Fea's style. Green is too quick to agree, too distant.

#57: Nerwen is flip-flopping. Still suspects Brinn and Green. Feels okay about Aganzir, Volo, Mac. Legate and Valier seem innocent. Might's self-vote is odd: "suspicious in innocent way"

#80: Suspects Nerwen for defensiveness, but not pursuing her. Finds Kath's vote "futile." Plans to bring in a 4th candidate, though doesn't want double lynching.

Why would you bring in another candidate if you're worried about double lynching?

#91: Valier innocent for lurking comment, but furry for the seerish comment (the one's that's been discussed). Thinks Fea seems innocent. Legate's teacherish attitude is troublesome. Finds Nerwen's later posts more suspicious.

#126: Votes Nerwen. States it won't look good for her if Nerwen is innocent.

Nothing grabs me here. I find Lommy's arguments to mostly be quite reasonable.

Day 2

#137: Says Valier's death was because the wolfves thought she was the seer.

Note: she was the first to make this statement

#142: A long analysis. Basically, thinks the wolves thought Valier dreamt of morm, therefore he is guilty.

Through all this analysis, I find it strange she didn't even think of the possibilty that morm was framed.

#151: States that wolves will sacrifice one of their own to get rid of the seer. Finds Green's comments about her suspicious. Suspects morm and Green.

#156: Responding to Rikae. It's possible Valier's death was a framing, but why pick morm to frame?

Because morm was highly suspected yesterDay, therefore more lynchable.

#166: Says Farael makes good points on Rikae.

#185: Feels better about morm after post #175. Not certain.

#187: Innocent: Volo, Mac, Farael, Legate, Shasta
Neutral: Fea, Aganzir, Menel, Kath
Suspicious: Sally, Brinn, Might, Kuru, Morm, Green

Conclusion: Lommy seemed alright Day 1, but toDay her attitude towards morm is odd and it makes me very slightly suspicious of her. But still, I have doubts. After all, would a wolf really act as obvious as Lommy is?