Tol-In-Gauroth XXIV: Battle of the Band[Wagon]

[Boromir88]

Might I point out, Boro, that Volo also named you as 'talking sense'? I presume that means he was listing you as innocent. Meaning that you might also be the wolf hidden in his broad innocent list.~Celuien

I didn't include myself because whatever I would say would obviously be seen as biased. I left that up for other people like yourself to interpret because there's no point on doing an analysis on myself.

I'd be interested in hearing more about why you find me suspicious. Is there anything other than that Volo suspected me and that Menel also found me suspicious?

Relax just a little bit. If you notice I said I probably won't be voting for you today. But of those that Volo listed as 'suspicious' I find that you are the most wolfish looking one. Because of the death of Menel.

Now that you do bring this up, I'm growing more concerned over you Celuien, especially with this comment here:

As for Menel, the last thing I would do if I were a wolf accused by him would be to kill him at night. Too obvious, and I'm not that bold.

The game my brother was in last village Valesse said pretty much this exact same thing to me when he started suspecting her. And Valesse turned out to be a wolf. It may not be the same here, but I'm getting more concerned about you. It looks like if you are trying to convince me that it would be way too bold and foolish for you to do such a thing. Which is exactly what wolf-Valesse tried to do.

And also the expected move of an innocent who made a case and had it answered (partially) to his satisfaction.

That's true.