The Treason of Isengard: Eru's Plan?

[burrahobbit]

More words means you are more wrong.

the Noldor will return to Middle-earth, & Feanor will die there in the way he did

does not equal

Feanor chooses his road, but not his destination

If I take the road that heads east from here I will not end up in California, unless I turn onto the westward road. Similarly, if Feanor decided to be a peaceful fellow he would not have been killed by balrogs. To suggest otherwise is, to turn a phrase, "retarded."

Turin is not bound by the Music.

You are amazingly and fundamentally wrong.