Death portrayal

[Anguirel]

Well, the Rohirrim's "Death" chant, like so much that was breathtaking and moving in the films, was straight out of the book, of course!

As for your second statement-rather controversial. Boromir was not a failure in life-he was one of the greatest and clearest successes we know. He redeemed himself in battle, conquered his desire and died at peace. That is why his death, although solemn as befits him, and sad for those who love him, is actually a moment of heroism and joy. He has confessed and repented, and merely goes, as you say correctly, to his Father-and not the one that sits on the Steward's chair, at that.

Death is Illuvatar's gift, you're right. And this was portrayed well in general, I agree. Just have a bone to pick with you about poor old Boromir's supposed "failure".